Lives that helped make the field
Homes, money, care, writing, and clinical work often belonged to the same networks. These connections make a different history visible from one organized only around teachers and pupils.
Berlin & Stockholm · 1930s–1941
Karin Boye & Margot Hanel
Boye translated psychoanalytic writing for Clarté and underwent analysis with Alfhild Tamm. She met Margot Hanel while living in Berlin. Hanel later joined her in Stockholm, where they shared a home. Boye’s 1934 novel Crisis follows a young woman’s struggle with her love for another woman and the religious condemnation surrounding it.
Lindqvist, 2008, pp. 65–66.
Explore their network
London · before 1920
Jessie Murray & Julia Turner
Their shared life intersects with their institutional work. Murray and Turner helped establish the Medico-Psychological Clinic in 1913 and their home accommodated treatment. The clinic brought psychological approaches together. Mossop sees their partnership within the longer history of women’s shared lives in psychoanalysis, while Appignanesi and Forrester connect their work to May Sinclair’s support.
Mossop, 2025, pp. 143–144; Appignanesi & Forrester, 1992; Bates, 2024.
Explore their network · Home & clinic
Vienna, England & The Hague · 1912–1922
Anna Freud & Loë Kann
Before Anna’s intimate correspondence with Eva Rosenfeld or her shared life with Dorothy Burlingham, there was Loë Kann. She was in analysis with Anna’s father when the women became friends. In July 1914 Anna told Freud she dreamed about Loë often and was extraordinarily fond of her; in July 1915, she was still dreaming about her nightly. They planned to meet again at the 1920 Hague Congress, but Loë didn’t come. Writing to Lou Andreas-Salomé in December 1922, Anna compared friendship to falling in love and remembered Loë among attachments whose endings had left even the past feeling ruined.
The editors of the Anna–Lou letters suggest Anna probably fell in love with Loë without having her feelings returned in the same way. That’s an interpretation of Anna’s letters, not an established sexual or reciprocal romance. Her affection, dreams, longing and disappointment are in the surviving record.
Freud & Freud, 2014, letters 45 AF and 53 AF; Rothe & Weber, 2003, Vol. 1, letter 66; Vol. 2, editorial notes; Young-Bruehl, 2008.
Explore their connection · Loë inside Freud’s clinical circle
Vienna & Göttingen · 1919–1937
Anna Freud & Lou Andreas-Salomé
Their letters make longing unmistakable. Anna writes of jealousy, “possession,” and how deeply Lou has become part of her life; Lou imagines holding Anna close and describes them as living in the same “inner room.” Kisses, gifts, and hoped-for visits sit alongside fiction, clinical cases, teaching, papers, and questions of transference. Their intellectual companionship wasn’t separate from their affection: they trusted each other with unfinished ideas and sometimes resisted each other’s interpretations. The two volumes preserve the intensity of what they expressed, while leaving the nature of physical intimacy open.
Their correspondence about Edith Rischawy reveals another dimension of their intimacy: how a mutual friend and patient became part of their questions about sexuality, privacy, exclusivity, and the right to be understood on one's own terms. Read Edith Between Anna and Lou.
Rothe & Weber, 2003, Vol. 1, Letter 66; Vol. 2, Letter 372.
Read Anna & Lou’s letters · Explore their connection
Vienna & London · from 1925
Anna Freud & Dorothy Burlingham
They met in 1925 and built a shared domestic and professional life. Dorothy’s contribution was more than supporting Anna. The museum study follows her work on maternal empathy, twins, and blindness. The 2026 editorial also discusses her role in developing the Hampstead Index. Their partnership and Dorothy’s intellectual work are more visible through Mossop’s work.
Mossop & Meadows, 2026, manuscript pp. 8, 13–15; Meadows et al., 2026, pp. 1, 5–6.
In 1942, Dorothy imagined a small, simple home, perhaps a duplex, where she and Anna could live together and each have some privacy. She wanted her own things around her, her own way of doing things, and the freedom to invite someone without requiring the other to join them. She also valued the life they’d made together.
Writing to her son Bob on May 28, 1944, she weighed her longing for her children and grandchildren against her attachment to Anna: “I also cannot imagine not sharing Annafreud’s life. I think we need each other probably more than ever.” She imagined continuing to work where Anna worked, spending long holidays with her family, and welcoming them to London.
Dorothy’s letters of August 29 and December 28, 1942, and May 28, 1944, reproduced and discussed in Burlingham, 1989; source notes.
A letter from Anna Freud to Max Eitingon, dated February 19, 1926, offers unusually direct evidence of the conflict between Anna’s professional role and her personal attachment to Dorothy Burlingham’s children.
While analyzing Bob and Mabbie Burlingham, Anna recognized that she wanted not only to improve their health but also to have something of the children, and their mother, for herself. She worried that this desire might interfere with their treatment and felt ashamed to discuss it with her father. This is Anna’s own acknowledgment of an emotional conflict within her clinical work. It precedes the fuller development of the household and family life she shared with Dorothy.
Michael John Burlingham, Dorothy’s grandson, later interpreted Anna’s position as a form of analytic stepparenting. He connected her work with the children to her wish for a family and to the problem of altruistic surrender explored during her second analysis with Sigmund Freud in 1924–1925. His account is valuable as family testimony and historical interpretation.
Anna Freud to Max Eitingon, February 19, 1926, quoted in Young-Bruehl, 1988; source note, n. 74. Burlingham, 1991, pp. 615–617; Meyer-Palmedo, 2014, introduction.
Explore Dorothy’s connections · The household & treatment
Philadelphia · early twentieth century
Jessie Taft & Virginia Robinson
Taft and Robinson were partners, co-parents, and colleagues. Both had analysis with Otto Rank and developed his ideas in social work education. Their shared family and professional collaboration show how psychoanalytic thinking moved through social work and medical institutions. The atlas shows their domestic relationship separately from their analyses and teaching.
Hale, 1995b; further biographical sources accompany their existing records.
Explore Taft & Robinson
Modernist networks · 1918 onward
H.D., Bryher & their circle
Their letters place desire, art, financial support, and treatment in the same history. Bryher helped finance H.D.’s analyses. Other attachments, including H.D.’s relationship with Silvia Dobson, complicate a simple couple narrative. Magee and Miller describe institutional restrictions, political danger, bereavement and Bryher’s own ambivalence in her pursuit of analytic training.
Magee & Miller, 1997; Friedman, 2002.
Read the correspondence feature · Explore the circle
Vienna · the case published in 1920
Margarethe, Leonie & the case history
Margarethe Csonka-Trautenegg, known under the biographical pseudonym Sidonie Csillag, loved Leonie Puttkamer-Gessman. Her father wanted Freud to change her sexuality. Recent readings place her life and later recollections more clearly with the clinical account. Freud’s case history, Csillag’s later biography and recent theoretical readings present different perspectives on her life.
Monaco, 2025, “The Young Homosexual Woman” and “Freud and Sidonie”; Mossop & Meadows, 2026, manuscript pp. 23, 26–27.
Explore the relationships · Whose treatment aim?
Trieste, Vienna & Berlin · 1912–1921
Bruno Veneziani and the analytic network
Bruno Veneziani was analyzed by Sadger, Freud, Reitler, Tausk and Abraham, then treated at Groddeck’s sanatorium. Freud’s 1920 letter to Weiss discussed his homosexuality and refused another analysis. His story also entered the work of his brother-in-law Italo Svevo.
Borch-Jacobsen, 2021; May, 2018; Freud & Abraham, 2002; Weiss, 1991.
Explore his analysts · Treatment and family
Vienna & New York · 1924–1935
Carl Liebmann and fetishism
Freud’s 1927 paper included a patient whose fetish was an athletic support-belt. Borch-Jacobsen identifies him as Carl Liebmann. Freud’s letters to Pfister describe his work with the patient; Liebmann later sought treatment with Brunswick, Rank, Brill and Nunberg.
Borch-Jacobsen, 2021; Freud, 1927; Freud & Pfister, 1963.
Explore his analysts · Treatment and family finance
Postwar extension
Pearl King & Tina Carlile
The British psychoanalyst and Canadian artist shared lives for more than sixty years. Reporting on Noreen Giffney’s symposium contribution, Meadows, Mossop, and Soreanu wonder about encountering the relationship only near the end of King’s obituary. Professional silence itself becomes a historical question.
Meadows et al., 2026, p. 8. This relationship extends beyond the main historical period.
Explore King & Carlile
Continue through the atlas’s same-sex love and desire records, including the Strachey network. The Boundaries page examines the arrangements of care, authority and treatment within these networks.
Changing the questions about desire
These readings ask different questions about development, sexual difference, identification, clinical authority, and the analyst’s assumptions. The books and papers below are part of the reading behind this project.
Chicago cases and Ellis’s sexology
Chicago’s contribution to this history didn’t begin with its psychoanalytic institute. James G. Kiernan and G. Frank Lydston helped make the city a center of American sexology in the 1880s. They published accounts of patients’ sexual lives and supplied case studies to European sexologists, including Havelock Ellis.
Heap, 2000.
Freud named Ellis among the sources for the factual material in the first of his Three Contributions to the Theory of Sex. Ellis’s work connects Chicago’s medical case writing with the sexological literature Freud drew on.
Freud, 1905/1920.
Explore Ellis’s connections · Freud in Chicago’s bohemia.
Freud and Fliess: bisexuality and homosexuality, 1890s–1904
Wilhelm Fliess proposed that male and female characteristics existed within each person. Freud discussed the theory with him during the 1890s and incorporated psychic bisexuality into his developing account of repression and sexuality. The two men debated the relationship between bodily differences, sexual longing, and psychological conflict.
In October 1899 Freud connected early sexual wishes with homosexuality and masturbation. In July 1904 Fliess objected to the appearance of related ideas in Otto Weininger’s 1903 book. Freud described how his patient Hermann Swoboda had spoken with Weininger, a close friend, about bisexuality after discussing it in treatment.
These letters precede Lou Andreas-Salomé’s discussions of psychic bisexuality with Freud in 1912–1913 and the later disagreements among analysts about same-sex desire, including Sándor Radó’s 1940 rejection of universal bisexuality. Follow the changing theory on Timeline.
Freud’s letters to Fliess, 1890s–1904.
Lou Andreas-Salomé’s 1912 journal: homosexuality and bisexuality
In November 1912, Lou attended Alfred Adler’s presentation of a patient’s homosexuality as a neurotic fiction. Her objection was methodological as well as personal: a reading of one case couldn’t establish that every homosexual desire worked in that way. She distinguished an enduring sexual organization from a case-specific analytic explanation.
That resistance to generalizing wasn’t an unqualified modern affirmation. Lou’s own notes elsewhere still used developmental hierarchies, assumptions about masculine and feminine traits, and language that could pathologize desire. In February 1913 she recorded Freud suggesting that psychic bisexuality could enrich development without necessarily disturbing it.
Andreas-Salomé, The Freud Journal, 1987 (contemporary entries, November 1912–February 1913).
Follow this debate from 1912 through 1944 on the Timeline.
Erotic cruelty, Nietzsche, and Lou’s contradictory freedoms
In a 1913 reflection on cruelty and compassion within love, Lou recalled discussing the subject with Friedrich Nietzsche many years earlier. She applied the language of sadomasochism to his inward relation to himself and remembered their mutual embarrassment. Lou recorded this recollection in her 1913 journal.
Across the journal she also explored women’s erotic autonomy, fidelity, and the possibility of loving more than one person. Those passages sit beside prescriptive ideas about gender, masturbation, and homosexuality. These contradictions make Lou a revealing witness to the sexual thinking of her era.
Andreas-Salomé, The Freud Journal, 1987 (1913 reflections, including her retrospective Nietzsche story).
Where love and analytic work met: Rilke and Tausk
In October 1913 Lou explored dreams with her former lover and continuing friend Rainer Maria Rilke. Her journal preserves part of a dream in his own hand. She stopped interpreting when she felt the work would encroach on his poetic imagination. The encounter shows both the reach of analytic thinking into love and a limit she chose to respect; it wasn’t a formal treatment.
Her relationship with Viktor Tausk was different. The journal describes working beside him at von Frankl-Hochwart’s neurological outpatient clinic in 1912–1913, discussing analytic technique and narcissism, and talking with Freud about Tausk. Their romance, shared work, and different loyalties overlapped; the 1919 Deutsch–Tausk treatment conflict came later.
Andreas-Salomé, The Freud Journal, 1987.
Lou and Rilke’s dream conversations · Lou and Tausk’s clinic work · Explore Lou’s network.
Freud’s contradictions and the authority to define a treatment
O’Connor and Ryan trace changes and tensions in Freud’s accounts of lesbianism. Their discussion looks at how explanatory theories become judgments about a person’s development. Monaco’s return to Margarethe’s case asks whose desire organizes the treatment and challenges a reading that places a woman who loves women automatically in a masculine position. These are readings of Freud and Lacan.
Mossop’s discussion of Anna Freud and Robert “Bob” Burlingham also brings domestic life into conversation with clinical attitudes toward homosexuality.
O’Connor & Ryan, 1993; Monaco, 2025, “Freud and Sidonie”; Mossop, 2025, pp. 149–150.
Follow the debates about same-sex desire and pathology on the Timeline.
Anna-Antigone: a daughter’s life and a life with Dorothy
On May 2, 1935, Freud called Anna “my faithful Anna-Antigone” in a letter to Arnold Zweig. He explained that he couldn’t travel to Mount Carmel even with her help. Patrizia Cupelloni takes up this image of the devoted daughter while arguing that Anna’s life and thought grew beyond the role her father gave her. She reads Anna’s relationship with Dorothy as a source of mutual recognition, pleasure and creativity that helped her develop work of her own. In Cupelloni’s interpretation, The Ego and the Mechanisms of Defense was both a gift to her father and an expression of intellectual independence.
Cupelloni, 2000, “Antigone,” “Something more,” and concluding discussion; PDF pp. 6, 9–10, 14; n. 32, PDF p. 16. Freud’s letter is quoted through Cupelloni, who cites the 1970 Freud–Zweig correspondence.
Patricia Gherovici returns to Anna-Antigone in 2026, reading Anna’s partnership with Dorothy as a reworking of family, desire and the passing on of psychoanalysis. Their shared life brought together love, care for Dorothy’s children and professional collaboration. For Gherovici, Anna worked within the Freudian tradition while stretching its expectations about how a woman could love and make a family. The partnership becomes part of Anna’s intellectual legacy: she preserved her father’s work while making something of her own from relationships that exceeded its familiar family pattern.
Gherovici, 2026, pp. 59–60.
Anna Freud and homosexual candidates · Later British history
In Britain, Anna Freud opposed admitting a homosexual applicant to her child-study course in 1948. Writing to Dr. Gomperts on October 28, she placed such applicants among people with “sexual abnormalities” whom institutions shouldn’t admit.
In 1956, she asked Nancy Procter-Gregg not to quote her father’s 1935 letter on homosexuality in The Observer. She argued that analysts could now cure more homosexual patients and feared that readers would take the letter as encouragement to accept their homosexuality.
Young-Bruehl records a later change in Anna’s position on training. Citing Leo Rangell’s 1983 memorial account, she reports that Anna came to accept qualified homosexual candidates without requiring a “cure.”
Young-Bruehl, 2008; source notes, nn. 23–25. Anna Freud to Dr. Gomperts, October 28, 1948, and to Nancy Procter-Gregg, February 27, 1956, quoted or discussed in the biography. Rangell’s later recollection gives no date for her change of position.
For the later American institutional history, see APsA’s 1991 nondiscrimination policy.
Weiss, Tausk, and homosexual patients
In Vienna, Edoardo Weiss referred a young homosexual man to Viktor Tausk. Weiss recalled that Tausk wanted to relieve the young man's guilt about his sexuality so he could have the sexual life he wanted. Weiss and Tausk had worked together at von Frankl-Hochwart's neurological clinic and discussed their patients and Freud's work.
In a letter to Weiss on 3 October 1920, Freud declined to treat another patient, Dr. A., whose problems Weiss described as including addictions. Borch-Jacobsen identifies Dr. A. as Bruno Veneziani. Freud said he wasn't considering the man's homosexuality as a reason to refuse him. He wrote: “He could remain that and still live normally and rationally.” May’s reconstruction dates Veneziani’s 187 sessions with Freud to October 1912–May 1913; Abraham’s correspondence names him as a subsequent patient in 1914.
Weiss's account of Mr. F. G. records a different treatment, beginning in 1920. The man told Weiss he had experienced homosexual desire since childhood and had suffered intense guilt. During analysis he began reporting desire for women, married, and recovered from a severe depression. He also developed increasingly severe asthma attacks. Weiss attributed the asthma to changes brought about in analysis and later wrote that the patient had reason to blame the treatment. Mr. F. G. became angry with Weiss and Freud and ended his analysis.
Weiss, 1991; Borch-Jacobsen, 2021; May, 2018; Freud & Abraham, 2002. The 1920 passage is Freud's dated letter; the Tausk referral and Mr. F. G.'s treatment history are Weiss's later recollections.
Heterosexuality also has a history
Chodorow’s argument shifts the burden: heterosexuality, like other sexualities, has a particular psychic history. Chodorow’s account challenges the assumption that homosexual development is pathological. O’Connor and Ryan’s discussion of Stephen Mitchell’s 1981 intervention similarly questions the analyst’s authority to prescribe a heterosexual outcome. These arguments change what an analyst is asking of a patient, as well as what theory assumes needs explaining.
In her 1992 paper, Chodorow follows the fantasies, defenses, identifications and relationships through which a person gives sexuality its particular meaning. She follows the different ways heterosexual attachments combine longing, fear, rivalry and wishes for protection. She treats this combination as a compromise formation: an individual solution to wishes and conflicts, with its own history. Heterosexuality becomes something psychoanalysis has to understand on the same terms as homosexuality.
For Chodorow, the clinical questions concern the quality of a person’s relationships: intimacy, mutuality, compulsiveness, freedom and the capacity to recognize another person. Those questions run through heterosexual and homosexual lives. The analyst’s work follows what a particular relationship means to this person, including how that meaning develops in the transference.
Chodorow, 1992; O’Connor & Ryan, 1993 (their account of Mitchell).
Edith Rischawy and the heterosexual future
In June 1925, Lou Andreas-Salomé worried that analysis might help Edith Rischawy become more sensual without giving her access to what Lou considered a woman's natural sexual fulfillment. She believed men had shown an inexplicable lack of interest in Edith.
Anna Freud challenged her. Which men were supposedly refusing Edith? Perhaps Hans Lampl, she suggested, but he was exceptionally demanding.
The disagreement reveals something important about the sexual assumptions guiding psychoanalysis. Lou was concerned that helping a woman become more sexually alive could also make her unhappy if she couldn't obtain a heterosexual relationship. Anna questioned the evidence that such a relationship was unavailable.
But the women making these judgments were themselves joined by an extraordinarily intimate attachment. Their correspondence included longing, expressions of love, bodily imagination, gifts, jealousy, and a wish for mutual recognition. Anna's later life with Dorothy Burlingham would give still another form to women's shared emotional and domestic lives.
There’s a striking difference between the sexual future Lou imagined for Edith and the forms of intimacy that mattered in Anna's and Lou's own lives.
The question isn't simply what Edith desired. It's how the analysts' ideas of femininity, sexuality, and fulfillment shaped what they thought treatment ought to accomplish.
Sources: Anna–Lou correspondence, Volume 2, Lou to Anna, 5 June 1925, Letter 237; Anna to Lou, 20 June 1925, Letter 238; Lou to Anna, 19 November 1926, Letter 286; Volume 1.
Continue reading: Edith Rischawy: Friendship, Analysis, and the Right to a Private Life · Edith Between Anna and Lou.
Lesbian desire, difference, and the meanings of closeness
Burch challenges the assumption that intimacy or merger in a lesbian relationship necessarily indicates pathological symbiosis. She requires us to deal with differences between women and their relationships. De Lauretis approaches the problem of how lesbian desire isn’t adequately described as identification with women, general sisterhood, or a maternal bond. Her writing develops a vocabulary of fantasy and “perverse desire” within psychoanalytic theory.
Glassgold and Iasenza’s edited collection makes lesbian analysts and patients participants in revising psychoanalytic knowledge. Its introduction documents a struggle over theory, training, and professional belonging in the 1990s.
Burch, 1997; de Lauretis, 1994; Glassgold & Iasenza, 1995.
Queer and trans encounters with psychoanalytic concepts
Giffney and Watson bring clinical practice and queer theory into conversation. Stryker examines transgender experience in conversation with queer theory. Trans experience can challenge how psychoanalysis thinks about embodiment, identification, and sexual difference—thinking concepts through lived experience.
Mossop offers a different contemporary intervention by reading Anna Freud’s fantasy writing through queer and BDSM perspectives. That’s an explicitly situated interpretation of a text—and fascinating.
Giffney & Watson, 2017; Stryker, 2017, pp. 419–426; Mossop, 2025, pp. 150–152.
Later theory · 1991–2008
Later perspectives on female sexual development
These later readings follow the relationships among bodily pleasure, the mother, the father and a woman’s sense of herself as someone who desires. Nancy Kulish and Deanna Holtzman, Dianne Elise and Ruth Fischer develop distinct accounts of those relationships.
The Persephone complex and the continuing maternal relationship
Nancy Kulish and Deanna Holtzman place the continuing relationship with the mother at the center of female development. In A Story of Her Own, they use Persephone’s movement between Demeter and the underworld to describe conflicts over desire, rivalry, separation and return. The mother remains loved and desired as the daughter becomes interested in the father. In their account, the girl adds an erotic object and negotiates changing loyalties between both parents.
Their triangle contains more than a contest for the father. A daughter wants closeness with her mother while also wanting a sexual life that belongs to her. Her mother becomes an object of desire, a source of identification and a rival. Kulish and Holtzman describe these positions as shifting: attachment, resentment, longing and identification move between mother and father as the girl develops.
Holtzman and Kulish’s earlier paper on separation makes a clinical argument about this retained maternal relationship. They locate fears of losing the mother within the girl’s triangular sexual conflicts. An analyst who interprets every intense maternal attachment as an earlier developmental stage misses the rivalry and desire within it. Their Persephone model gives separation and reunion a place alongside erotic wishes, with the daughter’s continuing love for her mother woven into the triangle.
Kulish & Holtzman, 2008; Holtzman & Kulish, 2000.
Female pleasure, bodily meaning and sexual agency
Kulish’s work on the clitoris begins with a problem in interpretation: analysts have often read its images through masculine or phallic meanings. Her clinical material follows the female bodily sensations and fantasies contained in dreams. Clitoral imagery carries excitement, curiosity, control and aggression. She gives the clitoris a place in the girl’s and woman’s mental representation of her own female sexuality.
Her paper on primary femininity asks what analysts mean when they describe something as primary. The term has gathered several claims: early genital awareness, bodily sensation, gender identity, anxiety and the first relationship with the mother. Kulish separates these meanings and examines what each contributes. She values the attention to female bodily experience while challenging the idea that femininity reaches an innate, finished core. An individual woman’s fantasies and relationships remain part of the explanation.
Holtzman and Kulish’s study of aggression adds another dimension to sexual agency. They describe girls and women who soften, conceal or attribute their competitive wishes to others because their anger seems to threaten a safe relationship with the mother. Sexual desire and rivalry become entangled: wanting something for oneself also means confronting the wish to compete. They connect a woman’s difficulty claiming pleasure with difficulty owning aggression. Analysis brings these wishes together as parts of her own experience, so desire, ambition and assertiveness have room in her account of herself.
Kulish, 1991; Kulish, 2000; Holtzman & Kulish, 2003.
Secrets, pleasure and intimacy
In her paper on secrecy, Kulish follows the pleasures of keeping something private and of choosing someone with whom to share it. A secret creates distance, control and anticipation. Sharing it creates a different intimacy, especially in the relationships between girls and women. Her clinical cases show how a woman’s excitement about speaking coexists with shame about what she wants.
Kulish attends to the act of telling as well as the concealed material. Who knows, who’s excluded, and who gets invited into confidence become part of the erotic and emotional exchange. She connects sexual inhibition with the difficulty of acknowledging desire as one’s own. The analytic conversation carries both a wish to reveal pleasure and the pleasure of revealing it.
Kulish, 2002.
The mother as an erotic object
Dianne Elise starts with the daughter’s erotic attachment to her mother. She calls this the primary maternal oedipal situation and asks how the mother receives the girl’s desire. The central question is recognition: whether the daughter encounters her mother as someone who recognizes her as a desiring girl. Elise places female homoerotic desire inside the account of female development from its beginning.
For Elise, a daughter’s turn toward the father takes its meaning from this earlier relationship. An interest in him enlarges her erotic world or offers refuge when desire for the mother has met rejection or silence. Her argument follows the difference between adding another desired person and using that attachment to escape a desire that feels unacceptable. The mother–daughter relationship continues to shape fantasy and later love.
Elise links the obscuring of this early erotic tie to the stigmatization of lesbian desire. If a girl’s longing for her mother becomes visible only as dependence or identification, her position as a sexual subject disappears from the theory. Elise’s account gives female same-sex desire a place in psychic life, in heterosexual as well as lesbian relationships. Her use of psychic bisexuality concerns the mind’s capacity for multiple identifications and erotic attachments.
Elise, 2002.
Lesbian development and individual histories
Ruth Fischer examines the individual histories within lesbian development. She challenges the sequence in which a girl must move from masculinity to femininity, from the clitoris to the vagina, and from the mother to the father. In her account, relationships with both parents develop alongside one another. A growing paternal attachment leaves the maternal relationship active, with its own erotic wishes, identifications and conflicts.
Fischer distinguishes psychodynamics, psychopathology and sexual object choice. A woman’s relationship with another woman has meanings shaped by her life; understanding those meanings is a different task from explaining why she desires women. The conflicts that appear in one lesbian patient’s history also appear in heterosexual histories. The clinical question follows the particular organization of desire, anxiety and relationship.
In her account of Alice, fantasies, relationships and understanding of desire change during treatment; Alice’s sexual object choice remains unsettled at the paper’s end. Fischer discusses biological and environmental contributions to orientation alongside the meanings of Alice’s attachments. The case preserves a person’s changing experience within a paper that separates the interpretation of conflict from a diagnosis based on sexual object choice.
Fischer, 2002.
For the clinical interpretations, continue to Later clinical perspectives on Boundaries.
What the archive preserves
Mossop and Meadows describe a 1975 note recording the withdrawal of personal letters from the Anna Freud–Dorothy Burlingham correspondence. They also discuss a surviving letter marked “To destroy.” Such traces establish that the archive was selected. A queer reading can ask why a shared life was minimized, whose work was overlooked, and what a display makes imaginable, while still leaving unanswered questions open.
Mossop & Meadows, 2026, manuscript pp. 20–22; Meadows & Mossop, 2025; Mossop, 2026, pp. 65–68, 74.
In the preface to the 2008 edition of her biography, Elisabeth Young-Bruehl placed the question of Anna and Dorothy’s sexual activity within the wider history of their love, work, and the profession’s prejudice. She described the sexual question as perhaps unanswerable.
Young-Bruehl, 2008, preface.
In a 2009 essay, Young-Bruehl returned to the account of Anna and Dorothy in her biography. She still favored an ascetic reading, but said she should have acknowledged that she couldn’t establish what form their erotic tie took. She also said the biography should have examined the psychoanalytic world’s hostility to homosexuality and what that might have meant for Anna. Her own reconsideration belongs in the history of how this relationship has been told.
Young-Bruehl, 2013, pp. 168–170, 174–176 (essay originally published in 2009).
Reading the references. Page links lead to the bibliography below; the atlas records give claim-specific citations. Later testimony, historical reconstruction, and contemporary interpretation are identified as such. Unresolved dates remain unassigned.
Personal histories / through 1945
Love, sex & partnership
Marriage, shared households, affairs and desire are part of this network’s history. Each has its own connection, alongside analysis, teaching and collaboration. Shared lives aren’t necessarily analytic lineage.
Begin with Alix Strachey, Josephine Dellisch, Nancy Morris and James Strachey. Their biographies distinguish sexual partnerships from unevenly reciprocated attachments and explain work, nursing, money and treatment arrangements.
Explore same-sex love and desire · Explore same-sex domestic partnerships · Dellisch’s treatment network
Historical accounts of same-sex relationships and attachments make lesbian, gay and bisexual histories discoverable. This expansion covers relationships through 1945; later testimony may establish earlier events.
Intellectual history / Soviet psychology, 1925–early 1930s
Vygotsky, Luria and Freud: the Soviet debate
In 1925, Lev Vygotsky and Alexander Luria introduced the Russian translation of Freud’s Beyond the Pleasure Principle with interest in what a materialist psychology could take from psychoanalysis. That didn't mean agreement. Vygotsky questioned the claim that reflexes could adequately explain consciousness and rejected attempts to make Freud’s theories Marxist with a declaration.
In his work on higher mental functions, written in the early 1930s, Vygotsky criticized psychoanalysis for reducing cultural developments to underlying sexual drives. But he also credited Freud with showing how apparently insignificant details could disclose larger psychological processes. Vygotsky’s alternative placed the social and historical formation of higher mental functions at the center of inquiry. Freud was neither simply adopted nor simply dismissed.
The political setting also changed. Soviet authorities increasingly restricted independent approaches to psychology. Those institutional pressures are different from Vygotsky’s scientific criticisms of Freud.
Sources: Vygotsky & Luria (1925/1994), pp. 10–18; Vygotsky (1997); Maher (2026), pp. 166–173; Radzikhovskii (1992), pp. 70–77. For a later interpretation of Vygotsky’s emphasis on practice, see Mecacci (2021), pp. 729–733.
Regional history / Italy, 1908–1940
Edoardo Weiss and psychoanalysis in Italy
Edoardo Weiss first visited Freud in Vienna on 7 October 1908. He was analyzed by Paul Federn and became a member of the Vienna Psychoanalytic Society in 1913. After the First World War he practiced in Trieste, translated Freud's work into Italian, and consulted Freud about patients by letter and during visits. He also continued discussing psychosis and ego psychology with Federn.
Marco Levi Bianchini, director of the psychiatric hospital at Nocera Inferiore, published Italian translations of Freud, including Weiss's translation of the Introductory Lectures. In 1925 he told Freud he'd founded an Italian Psychoanalytical Society. Weiss objected that the hospital assistants named as its members hadn't undergone psychoanalytic training. On 30 September 1926 Freud wrote that the institutional form could precede the substance and encouraged Weiss to help build it. Weiss, 1991.
Weiss moved to Rome in 1931. Nicola Perrotti and Emilio Servadio approached him after reading his Elementi di Psicoanalisi, published with an introduction by Freud. Both entered training analysis with Weiss and helped organize the society. The group met weekly at Weiss's home. Cesare Musatti, a professor of psychology in Milan, became a member and attended meetings in Rome. Perrotti helped found the Rivista Italiana di Psicoanalisi; Servadio translated Freud's essay on Michelangelo's Moses for it. On 8 May 1932 Freud told Weiss that he'd recommended the Rome group's acceptance to Max Eitingon while retaining the international association's requirement that members be analyzed. Weiss, 1991.
Weiss left his hospital position in 1927 rather than join the Fascist Party. He reported an order to suspend the Rivista in late 1933 and further attempts to preserve its publication in 1934–1935. In his memoir he also disputed Ernest Jones's claim that he'd been in contact with Mussolini over Freud's safety; Weiss said he never had such contact and didn't believe the reported intervention. Weiss and his family emigrated to the United States in January 1939. He worked first at the Menninger Clinic in Topeka and joined Franz Alexander's Chicago circle in 1940. Weiss, 1991.
Explore Weiss's professional connections · Freud's advice about analyzing a son · Homosexuality in Weiss's clinical accounts.
Regional history / China, 1912–1939
Translation and clinical practice in China
Qian Zhixiu discussed psychoanalysis in 1912; Chinese translations of Freud followed. The 1929–1930 translations belong to this history of intellectual reception.
Bingham Dai brought psychotherapy into Peking Union Medical College in 1935–1939, following analysis with Sullivan and training with Leon Saul in Chicago.
Varvin & Gerlach, 2011, History section; Chiang, 2021, pp. 162, 167–171.
Chinese reception on the Timeline · Interpersonal psychoanalysis.
Prague / translations, Surrealism, and psychoanalysis
Brouk, Štyrský, and the Surrealist circle
Freud’s ideas reached Czech readers through translation and artistic experiment as well as clinical practice. In 1926, Ladislav Kratochvíl and Ota Friedmann prepared the first Czech edition of The Interpretation of Dreams with Emanuel Windholz’s help. During the 1930s, Bohuslav Brouk and Jindřich Štyrský gave dreams and sexuality a place in the Czech avant-garde’s publishing and political life.
Brouk had no formal analytic training. He published books on psychoanalysis and sexuality, helped finance Surrealist publications, and wrote a commentary for Štyrský’s Emilie Comes to Me in a Dream (1933). Štyrský supplied photomontages for the covers of Brouk’s Psychoanalytical Sexology and Balance of Psychoanalysis. Both men, along with Toyen and other artists, signed the Czech Surrealist Group’s 1934 manifesto. Their collaboration belonged to an artistic network distinct from the Prague clinical circle associated with Otto Fenichel, Annie Reich, Frances Deri, and Heinrich Löwenfeld.
For Brouk, erotic art could free pleasure from reproduction and challenge bourgeois morality. Štyrský combined dream narratives with images that brought desire, bodily fragmentation, and death together. Sobolewska argues that these works transformed psychoanalytic ideas through artistic practice. She emphasizes that Štyrský sought ways to express his dreams and left their interpretation to viewers and readers.
Their connections to Freud concern the reception of his ideas. Sobolewska also identifies Rank’s The Trauma of Birth as an influence on Brouk. Her comparisons with Reich and Gross describe intellectual affinities; her later comparisons with Marcuse and José Esteban Muñoz extend the interpretation into the history of sexual liberation and queer utopia.
Sobolewska, 2024, chapter 4.
Translations, books, and the 1934 group on the Timeline.
Poland / identity, psychiatric authority, and writing
Piotr Odmieniec Włast and the authority to describe a life
Piotr Odmieniec Włast published his early poetry and criticism as Maria Komornicka. In 1907 he began identifying as Piotr Odmieniec Włast. His family placed him in psychiatric institutions after he asserted his male identity. Writing to his mother from Opava in 1909, he defended that identity and demanded the freedom to work and develop his abilities. Sobolewska reads the letters as an effort to retain agency while his family and physicians claimed the authority to explain him.
His literary work became part of that struggle over interpretation. During the Second World War, his physician cousin Aleksander Oszacki wrote a psychological portrait using Włast’s The Devils, published in 1902. Oszacki treated the work as evidence of its author’s psyche and interpreted independence, intellect, and masculinity through ideas about incomplete feminine development. Literary historian Stanisław Pigoń, who’d met Oszacki in Sachsenhausen after the 1939 arrests of Kraków academics, had encouraged the essay.
Oszacki wasn’t a Freudian or a member of the psychoanalytic movement. Sobolewska places his essay beside psychoanalytic and sexological accounts of gender, tracing shared assumptions about development and the use of literature as psychological evidence. The availability of Freud’s works in Polish and German establishes a setting for that comparison; it doesn’t establish that Oszacki or Włast trained with Freud.
Pigoń published the essay in 1964 alongside family testimony and selections from Włast’s writing. That later publication brought the poet’s protests into a public account still shaped by relatives, a physician, and an editor. Sobolewska’s description of an anti-psychiatric voice concerns Włast’s resistance to those claims on his life. His letters and the wartime essay belong to the history before 1945; their later publication belongs to the history of how that life has been remembered.
Sobolewska, 2024, chapter 5.
Włast’s declaration and letters on the Timeline.
Featured network / Chicago, 1931–1945
Chicago’s Society and Institute
The Society came first. Founded in 1931 under N. Lionel Blitzsten, it elected its own officers and brought clinicians, researchers, and supporters together for scientific and professional exchange. The Institute opened in 1932 with its own trustees, director, staff, and training program. Many of the same people belonged to both institutions.
Blitzsten’s authority grew from his clinical practice, home discussion circle, and Society presidency, which he held from 1931 to 1934. He also served on the American Psychoanalytic Association’s Executive Council. His Institute role was different: he taught there, including an early-1933 dream-interpretation seminar with eight participants, but contested the standing offered to him. 1933 directory, pp. 526–527; 1933 training report, pp. 460–461.
The Society hosted clinical papers, elected members, received reports from congresses, and discussed training. The Institute administered its own faculty and program and also offered public and professional courses. Their separate governance coexisted with shared educational and scientific work. Pollock, 1977, pp. 5, 7–8; Pollock, 1983, pp. 13–14; 1934 Society proceedings.
Read the Boundary account: shared people, separate authority ↗
Different offices, overlapping people: the 1935 picture
| Person | Society position | Institute connection |
| N. Lionel Blitzsten | Founder; president, 1931–1934 | Alexander’s former analysand and an Institute lecturer; sought the deputy post later given to French. |
| Karl Menninger | President, 1934–1936 | Alexander’s former analysand, early candidate, and visiting lecturer, while maintaining his work in Topeka. |
| Thomas French | Vice-president, elected June 1934 | Alexander’s former analysand; original staff member and associate director from 1934. |
| Helen McLean | Secretary-treasurer, elected June 1934 | Original part-time clinician and teacher; connected to the University’s medical and social-work circles. |
| Alfred K. Stern | Honorary election, March 1934; listed as non-therapeutic in 1935 | Alexander’s former patient; founding patron and president of the Board of Trustees. |
1934 proceedings, pp. 526–527; 1935 directory, pp. 521–522; Lazar; Pollock, pp. 10–14.
Founding members and presidents through 1945
The charter dinner took place on June 8, 1931, at the Restaurant Francais, 1922 Calumet Avenue. The twelve charter members were Alexander, Bartemeier, Blitzsten, Hans Deutsch, Eisler, Alan Finlayson, French, Hamill, McLean, Menninger, Mohr, and George Morgenthau. They elected Blitzsten president, Eisler secretary-treasurer, and Alexander an honorary member.
| Years | Society president | A connection to the Institute |
| 1931–1934 | Blitzsten | Lecturer; Alexander’s former analysand. |
| 1934–1936 | Menninger | Lecturer and early candidate; Alexander’s former analysand. |
| 1936–1938 | French | Associate director; Alexander’s former analysand. |
| 1938–1940 | McLean | Founding clinician and teacher. |
| 1940–1942 | Mohr | Child-analysis clinician and teacher. |
| 1942–1944 | Eisler | Founding consultant and research associate. |
| From 1944; serving in 1945 | Gerard | Founding consultant, then staff member and child-analysis teacher. |
The Society’s narrative history places Gerard among its initial members. The dated charter identifies twelve founding members. The 1933 and 1935 directories document her active membership. 1933 directory; 1935 directory.
The Society’s full 1935 membership roster
Fourteen active members: Franz Alexander; Catherine Bacon; Leo Bartemeier; N. Lionel Blitzsten; Hans Deutsch; Edwin Eisler; Alan Finlayson; Thomas French; Margaret Gerard; Ralph Hamill; Hyman S. Lippmann; Helen McLean; Karl Menninger; George Mohr.
Four associate members: David Brunswick; Robert P. Knight; Lucia E. Tower; George Wilson.
Three non-therapeutic members: Herbert E. Chamberlain; Harold D. Lasswell; Alfred K. Stern.
These are the directory’s historical membership categories. The Society’s reach extended beyond Chicago: Menninger was based in Topeka, Bartemeier in Detroit, Finlayson in Cleveland, and Lippmann in St. Paul. 1935 directory, pp. 521–522.
Related links: Lasswell’s analyst, Theodor Reik · Lasswell’s letters · Chicago history.
The Society at work: meetings in 1934 and 1935
| Date | People | Society business or presentation |
| January 6, 1934 | Horney and Blitzsten | A joint report on the Washington psychoanalytic conference. |
| March 10, 1934 | Stern; Alexander, Bacon, and Wilson | Stern elected an honorary member. Institute gastrointestinal research presented: the research plan, gastric disturbances and personality, and spastic colitis. |
| June 23, 1934 | Menninger, French, and McLean | Elected president, vice-president, and secretary-treasurer. The meeting also received a Training Committee report. |
| October 6, 1934 | French, Alexander, and Menninger | Reports on the International Psychoanalytic Congress at Lucerne. |
| November 17, 1934 | Hamill | A paper on consciousness in petit mal. |
| November 9, 1935 | Alexander | Problems of psychoanalytic technique. |
| November 23, 1935 | Bacon | Envy of the mother and the wish to take from her. |
| December 7, 1935 | Society members | Business meeting. |
| December 21, 1935 | Hamill | Drawings by a nine-year-old girl with epilepsy. |
1934 proceedings, pp. 526–527; Autumn 1934 program; Autumn 1935 program.
Follow Blitzsten and Menninger’s contested Institute standing ↗
Featured network / Chicago, 1931–1942
How the first Institute group came together
Personal analysis, teaching, family connections, and philanthropy brought Chicago’s founding group into the same institution. French, Bacon, Blitzsten, Menninger, Saul, McLean, Mohr, and Bartemeier belonged to Alexander’s analytic circle. The Menninger correspondence identifies the Berlin and Chicago settings of several of these relationships. The founding patron Alfred Stern had been his patient as well.
Blitzsten’s Chicago Psychoanalytic Society began in 1931 with Menninger, French, McLean, Mohr, Hamill, Eisler, and Bartemeier among its charter members. Gerard appears in its 1933 active-membership roster. The independent Institute opened on October 3, 1932. Alexander, Horney, French, McLean, and Bacon were its original five staff members; Blitzsten and Menninger taught as visiting lecturers. 1933 membership; Pollock, 1977, p. 7; Lazar, 1994.
Read the connected Boundary accounts: analysis, appointments, and institutional power ↗
The original staff and visiting lecturers 7 people
The opening group| Person | Institute role | Earlier ties and route into the group |
|---|
| Franz Alexander | Director, 1932 | Berlin-trained analysand of Hanns Sachs. Hutchins and Franklin McLean recruited him to the University of Chicago in 1930; his Chicago patient Alfred Stern then organized the independent Institute’s funding and governance. |
| Karen Horney | Associate director, 1932–1934 | Alexander’s former Berlin teacher and fellow Sachs analysand. He sought her clinical and teaching experience and public appeal, offering $15,000 a year. Stern, the trustees, and Helen Swift Neilson participated in recruitment. |
| Thomas Morton French | Original part-time staff; associate director, 1934 | Entered analysis with Alexander in Berlin in 1926. Traveled through Europe with him to continue treatment. Alexander selected him over Blitzsten to succeed Horney. |
| Helen McLean | Original part-time staff, 1932 | Johns Hopkins medical graduate and University lecturer in medicine and social-work education. The Menninger correspondence’s editors identify her analysis with Alexander in Chicago alongside Karl Menninger and Bartemeier. Her husband Franklin encouraged her Vienna study and helped recruit Alexander; she taught while still training. |
| Catherine Lillie Bacon | Original part-time staff, 1932 | Alexander’s former patient. With French, traveled through Europe in the patient group known as “Alexander’s travelling circus.” Joined her former analyst as a salaried clinician and teacher. |
| N. Lionel Blitzsten | Visiting lecturer | Alexander’s analysand and Horney’s supervisee in Berlin. The Society’s history also names Rank; Alexander explicitly denied that treatment (Schechter, n. 14). Led the Chicago discussion circle and founded the Society in 1931. Protested exclusion from Institute planning and consultant status; wanted the deputy post later given to French. |
| Karl Menninger | Visiting lecturer and trainee | Alexander’s analysand from 1930; participant in Blitzsten’s circle; David Levy’s Harvard classmate, close friend, and fellow founder of the American Orthopsychiatric Association. Attended January 1932 planning meetings and contested consultant status. Taught in 1932–33 while training and working in Topeka. |
|---|
Menninger’s May–June 1932 letters challenged Stern’s failure to consult the Society and the status offered to himself and Blitzsten. Alexander’s June 16 revision called McLean and Bacon clinical associates, French both clinical associate and lecturer, and Menninger and Blitzsten lecturers. The preliminary consultant designation and later lecturer title belong to different stages of planning. Menninger correspondence. Lazar; Grinker manuscript.
Conflicting accounts. French’s promotion is dated 1934 in Pollock, 1983, p. 14 and Schmidt, 2010, p. 76; Pollock gives 1932 in the 1977 history (p. 13) and again in 1983 (p. 20). Lazar calls Horney Alexander’s first choice; Pollock says Helene Deutsch first declined an offer. Stern recalled making the recruitment call himself; Fisher recalled Schwarz arranging it and Alexander speaking while the organizers advised him on terms (Lazar; Pollock, 1983, pp. 10–12, 19 n. 2).
McLean’s Chicago analysis: Menninger correspondence, n. 14. The relationship is also listed by Mit Freud in Berlin, Alexander biography. Clinical and teaching routes: Lazar; Quinn; Pollock, pp. 10–14, 20.
The early additions and the Vienna child-analysis route 6 people
Early colleagues through 1942| Person | Institute role | Earlier ties and route into the group |
|---|
| Leon J. Saul | Early staff and research participant | Began analysis with Alexander as a Boston psychiatric resident and followed him to Chicago. Horney supervised his first case. Included in conferences and research meetings from the start, he remembered a family atmosphere and little hierarchy. |
| George Wilson | Early staff; research associate | Came from Detroit soon after the opening. Grinker recalled his informal instruction in dream interpretation. |
| George Mohr | Child-analysis faculty | An Alexander analysand in Berlin by February 1928; returned from child-analysis training with Anna Freud in Vienna soon after the Institute’s founding. Gerard and Ross subsequently joined him on the staff. |
| Margaret Gerard | Founding consultant; later child-analysis faculty | Original Society member in 1931 and University of Chicago consultant in 1932. Trained with Anna Freud in Vienna; joined Mohr and Ross in teaching and children’s case conferences. |
| Helen Ross | Research associate; administrative director, 1942 | Sought analysis with Alexander, who directed her to Vienna to work with Helene Deutsch and Anna Freud. Returned to Chicago and helped build the child-analysis program, which had three graduates by 1942. |
| Therese Benedek | Faculty recruit, 1936 | Alexander invited her from Leipzig. Her route included analysis with Ferenczi, Berlin professional connections, pediatric training, and clinical research. |
|---|
Mohr, Gerard, and Ross brought a common Vienna teacher into Chicago’s child-analysis program. Ross’s referral by Alexander led to training abroad, research work in Chicago, and an administrative appointment. Saul’s path joined his own analysis, Horney’s supervision, and Institute employment.
Quinn; Pollock, 1977, pp. 7, 12; Pollock, 1983, pp. 19–20; Beiser, 1981, p. 3; Beiser, 1993, p. 23; Grinker manuscript.
The trustees, families, and funding 6 trustees
The first board of trustees| Person | Institute role | Earlier ties and route into the group |
|---|
| Alfred K. Stern | President | Alexander’s Chicago patient and a Rosenwald Fund director. Married Marion Rosenwald; his brother-in-law David Levy married her sister Adele. Organized funding, premises, trustees, and recruitment. |
| Sidney L. Schwarz | Vice-president | Also vice-president of Michael Reese Hospital’s board. Helped organize the Institute and arranged the transatlantic recruitment call to Horney, as recalled by Fisher. |
| Ludvig Hektoen | Treasurer | Pathologist, McCormick Institute director, and Institute of Medicine of Chicago board chairman. Had supported Adolf Meyer’s psychiatric research in the 1890s; helped Stern seek funding and recruit Cohn. |
| Walter T. Fisher | Secretary | Lawyer and son-in-law of juvenile-research and mental-hygiene patron Ethel Sturges Dummer. Drafted the bylaws approved on June 10, 1932. |
| Helen Swift Neilson | Trustee | Early financial supporter; worked with Alfred and Marion Stern to secure Horney’s appointment. |
| William F. Ogburn | Trustee | University of Chicago sociologist with longstanding interests in psychoanalysis and personality research. Had resigned from the NRC sex-research committee after the 1928 removal of its social-science work under Hektoen. |
|---|
Levy’s encouragement during a boat trip led Stern to contact Alexander for analysis in Chicago. In planning the Institute, Stern mediated between his brother-in-law’s restrictions on private practice and his former analyst’s demands for terms that could recruit senior clinicians. Franklin McLean, Julius Rosenwald’s physician and a Fund trustee, had already worked with Robert Hutchins to bring Alexander to the University.
Lazar; Pollock, pp. 10–12, 18–19.
The advisers and the research program 6 advisers
Founding advisers and Cohn’s recruitment| Person | Institute role | Earlier ties and route into the group |
|---|
| Max Eitingon | Founding adviser | Director and patron of the Berlin Institute, where Alexander had trained. |
| A. A. Brill | Founding adviser | A leading American psychoanalytic organizer. |
| William Healy | Founding adviser | Director of Boston’s Judge Baker Foundation. Invited Alexander to the 1930 mental-hygiene congress and collaborated with him in Boston. Menninger admired his child-guidance work. |
| David M. Levy | Planner and founding adviser | Former Chicago Institute for Juvenile Research clinician; chief of New York’s Institute for Child Guidance. Encouraged Stern to seek analysis and helped design the Institute’s salaried research model. |
| William Alanson White | Founding adviser | Superintendent of Saint Elizabeths Hospital in Washington, D.C. |
| Alfred E. Cohn | National advisory board, 1932 | Rockefeller Institute investigator recruited by Stern and Hektoen. Required a research-centered program and clinical admissions serving its scientific aims. Had worked with Franklin McLean on clinical and physiological research. |
|---|
The advisers connected Berlin training, American psychoanalytic organization, child guidance, public psychiatry, and laboratory medicine. Cohn’s insistence on scientific investigation shaped the program Stern presented to the board.
Pollock, pp. 10–11, 17–18; Lazar.
The medical and institutional consultants 7 consultants
The original consultant group| Person | Institute role | Earlier ties and route into the group |
|---|
| Leo Bartemeier | Consultant | Detroit psychiatrist, Alexander’s analysand alongside Karl Menninger in Chicago in 1930, and original Society member. |
| John Farill | Consultant | Rush Medical College. |
| Edwin Eisler | Consultant | Director of Michael Reese Hospital’s Mental Hygiene Clinic; also listed by Grinker as an Institute research associate. |
| Margaret Gerard | Consultant | University of Chicago; Society founding member and Anna Freud–trained child analyst. |
| Ralph C. Hamill | Consultant | Northwestern University; a founder of the American Psychoanalytic Association. |
| Paul Schroeder | Consultant | Director of the Institute for Juvenile Research. |
| H. Douglas Singer | Consultant | University of Illinois professor of psychiatry and head of neuropsychiatry. |
|---|
Pollock, p. 11; Society history; Grinker manuscript.
Regional history / Southern California, 1927–1945
From the study group to Hollywood
Thomas Libbin and Margrit Libbin arrived in Los Angeles in 1927. Ernst Simmel joined the community in 1934, and the Psychoanalytic Study Group of Los Angeles took shape in 1935. Its activities initially came under the Chicago Institute’s aegis and later the Topeka Institute, established in 1938. Frances Deri and Otto Fenichel were among the European émigrés who strengthened the group.
May Romm arrived from New York in 1938 after training analysis with Sándor Radó. Her Hollywood practice brought her into the Selznick family: she analyzed David O. Selznick and Irene Selznick and gave Irene’s sister Edith Goetz supportive treatment. In 1944 David engaged Romm as psychiatric adviser on Spellbound.
The film industry also entered the analytic consulting room. Simmel analyzed screenwriter Herman Mankiewicz; Fenichel analyzed his brother Joseph. Joseph’s July 1944 letter to Karl Menninger began a documented dispute over Hitchcock’s The House of Dr. Edwards. Menninger exchanged letters with producer Selznick, Romm and national association officers. Romm described her revisions with screenwriter Ben Hecht and mentioned a letter from Chicago analyst Lionel Blitzsten.
Farber & Green, 1993, chapters 1–3; Menninger, 1995, letters of July–October 1944.
Follow the 1944 Spellbound letters on the Timeline · Read the May Romm–Selznick Boundary account.
Letters and relationships / 1919–1945
The Menninger letters: Chicago, Topeka, and the wider circle
Karl Menninger’s correspondence follows the everyday workings of an analytic network: analyses and supervision, shared hotels, gifts and dinners, recruitment, teaching, fees, and professional disagreements. Family life and institutional authority repeatedly meet in the same relationships.
Analyses and routes into the profession Clinical formation
Family, friendship, and clinical authority Overlapping roles
Treatment, work, and accountability Institutional decisions
Menninger correspondence ↗
Sigmund Freud and Wilhelm Fliess: love, letters, and intellectual companionship
Freud and Fliess corresponded from 1887 to 1904. Their letters move between family news, medical problems, sexual theory, dreams, patients, and the private meetings they called congresses. The friendship began while Freud was developing the methods and ideas that became psychoanalysis.
Love and private congresses
Freud and Fliess arranged visits in Berlin, Vienna, and other cities. They exchanged family greetings, books, gifts, medical advice, and manuscripts. On 12 June 1895 Freud wrote, “Your kindheartedness is one of the reasons I love you” (Masson, 1985). In January 1896 he thanked Fliess for understanding, companionship, and renewed confidence in his work.
In the correspondence with Ferenczi in October 1910, Freud described the homosexual attachment he’d withdrawn after the painful end of his friendship with Fliess. Robert Fliess wrote in 1944 that he’d heard both men speak about the emotional importance of the relationship. Marie Bonaparte recorded Freud’s recollection of passionate friendship on both sides.
Freud’s connections in the Atlas · Fliess’s connections.
Sexuality, patients, and the 1904 dispute
Fliess’s bisexuality theory contributed to Freud’s developing ideas about repression and sexual development. They disagreed over the biological and psychological explanation. In July 1904 Fliess accused Otto Weininger of taking his ideas through Hermann Swoboda. Freud explained that Swoboda was his patient and that bisexuality had entered their treatment discussions. Swoboda was also Weininger’s friend. Read the dispute in Boundaries.
Freud also reported clinical matters to Fliess. In December 1897 he described Emma Eckstein independently treating a young female patient and returning to the subject of paternal sexual experiences. His letters also describe Fliess’s earlier surgery on Eckstein and the later referral and ten-week treatment of Mrs. D. in 1901. Eckstein’s history · Mrs. D.’s treatment.
In 1902 Freud told Fliess how former patient Elise Gomperz and current patient Marie Ferstel had helped secure his professorship by approaching the education minister. Their campaign and Freud’s appointment.
Dreams, manuscripts, and the survival of the correspondence
Fliess read Freud’s manuscripts and proofs of The Interpretation of Dreams, and the two discussed which dreams would appear in the book. Masson’s editorial notes identify a dream Freud removed after Fliess objected. The withdrawn dream.
After Wilhelm’s death in 1928, Ida Fliess asked about recovering her husband’s letters. In 1936–1937 Marie Bonaparte purchased Freud’s surviving letters from Reinhold Stahl. She protected them during the Nazi annexation of Austria and the Second World War, with a wartime deposit in the Danish Legation in Paris in 1941. Bonaparte’s preservation of the correspondence.
Freud, The Complete Letters of Sigmund Freud to Wilhelm Fliess, 1887–1904 (Masson, 1985).
The relationships in Freud and Jones’s letters
Their correspondence follows analytic formation, patients and families, publishing work, professional recognition, and the money that sustained institutions. The biographies and connections trace these relationships through the letters and the editor’s identifications.
Teachers, patients, and routes into the profession
Families and connected patients
Work, recognition, and institutional authority
Freud–Jones correspondence ↗. Read Jones’s account of his relationship with Ferenczi and the Rank dispute alongside those separate collections, which preserve different voices and chronologies.
Sándor Ferenczi and Ernest Jones: analysis, friendship and disagreement
Their letters place a former analyst and analysand in an unusually changeable relationship: friends, professional collaborators, sometimes rivals, and finally disputants over Ferenczi’s work. Translation, hospitality, clinical decisions and the fate of manuscripts all pass through the same personal connection.
The analysis and the work that followed
The edited collection covers 8 April 1911–22 March 1933 in 43 main numbered items (1 F–43 F), alongside separately identified fragments and missing-letter notices. Only three complete letters by Jones survive in that main sequence. The surviving collection preserves far more of Ferenczi’s letters than Jones’s.
- Ferenczi analyzed Jones in 1913; both men reported the experience to Freud, and Ferenczi subsequently described missing his pupil with affection. His offers of further analysis in 1914 and 1923–24 weren’t additional completed courses. The changing roles and refusals matter as much as the original treatment.
- They also worked together on Jones’s anxiety paper, translations into English, international visits and publication decisions. Disagreement over Rank and Ferenczi’s joint work in 1924 unfolded amid these professional and affectionate ties.
Women, patients and colleagues in the network
- Lou Andreas-Salomé made a substantive contribution to Ferenczi’s early thinking, which he acknowledged after their 1913 discussions.
- Katherine Jones appears as an intellectual participant as well as Jones’s wife: her criticism, together with Joan Riviere’s, led him to soften a 1924 review. Training and advocacy disputes involving Franklin, and the requests concerning Lydia and John Rickman, reveal how professional assessment could carry private information.
- The letters distinguish referrals, proposed analyses and treatment actually undertaken. Ferenczi and Jones also discussed how professional pressure shaped decisions about entering analysis.
The final letters and the question of publication
On 22 March 1933, Ferenczi thanked Jones for promising to publish his Wiesbaden paper. After Ferenczi died, Jones wrote to Freud on 3 June about withdrawing the translated, typeset English paper, citing Riviere’s criticism. The German publication and the withheld English appearance were different events. The letters preserve the judgments made by the participants during the publication dispute.
Ferenczi–Jones, Letters 1911–1933 (Karnac, 2013) — full source citation ↗. Edited by Ferenc Erős, Judit Szekacs-Weisz and Ken Robinson; translated by B. Schumacher. Text, editorial introductions and notes are distinguished above.
H.D., Bryher, and their analytic circle
Their correspondence follows successive analyses, a shared household, friendships, refugee assistance, and the money that supported treatment and institutions. The connections bring literary life into the everyday practice of psychoanalysis.
Analyses, friendships, and the shared circle
- H.D.’s treatment chronology: Chadwick in 1931, brief work with Sachs, Freud in 1933 and 1934, and Walter Schmideberg from 1935. Mary Chadwick’s biography identifies her work as a nurse and psychoanalyst.
- Walter Schmideberg’s circle: Kenneth Macpherson, Silvia Dobson, Dorothy Cole Henderson, Robert Herring, H.D., and Perdita Macpherson. Their letters follow the strains of arranging treatment among partners, relatives, and friends.
- Ellis and Freud: Their direct correspondence and reciprocal intellectual influence; affection, professional rivalry, and H.D.’s disclosures in analysis.
- Advice and informal hours: Ellis’s friendship and sexual counsel; Chadwick as H.D.’s analyst and friend; H.D.’s own analytic conversations with friends.
Patronage, training, and refuge
Read the connected Boundary accounts
H.D.–Bryher correspondence ↗
Joan Riviere between treatment and intellectual work
Freud’s letters to Riviere move between analysis, translation, gifts, family news, and scientific disagreement. They follow a relationship in which affection, professional opportunity, and analytic authority remained closely connected.
Analysis and the making of the English Freud
Gifts, care, and professional disagreement
Freud–Riviere letters ↗
Anna Freud and Lou Andreas-Salomé: intimacy and longing
Anna and Lou’s correspondence reflects a relationship of affection, intellectual companionship and growing clinical confidence. Kisses, gifts, imagined visits, fiction, teaching and papers share the page with difficult questions about patients and interpretation. Their letters express reciprocal affection, longing, creative recognition and intellectual companionship.
Anna’s own reports of analysis with her father are especially revealing. In May 1924 she described returning because her fantasies were compelling and distressing, and acknowledged the temptation to withhold material from someone so close to her outside treatment. In June, she wondered about the absence of a “third person” onto whom certain conflicts might be transferred, since her analyst was her father, after all. Their exchanges include advice about writing and transference, refusals of unsuitable analytic relationships, and choices about what patients or trainees could safely disclose.
Freud’s own letters to Lou expose the conflict on the other side of Anna’s analysis. On 3 July 1922 he said that Anna was inhibited in her relationships with men because of him, and described her disappointments with women friends. In May 1924 he worried about her libido and her future after his death. On 10 May 1925 he admitted that he couldn’t free Anna from himself and that no one was helping him. He could wish for her independence and fear losing her at the same time. These passages are reproduced by Peter Gay from archival correspondence; not all appeared in the published Freud–Lou letters. Gay (1989).
Their exchanges also carry emotionally close and erotic elements:
To Lou: From my earlier way of thinking, every “unfaithfulness” naturally had to wound me, because it made the goal—possession—impossible. I hope you will not be frightened, with all the nonsense that comes out of me, to discover how deeply you have already involved yourself with me.
Letter 66 — Anna to Lou, December 16, 1922 · Vol. 1
To Anna: My own, dear, dear Anna. I don't want to write at all, hardly even to speak. But to press you against me so tightly that you cry out—yes, that is what I want. For now, in our continuing experience of life, we have so much unspoken to communicate to one another. I am entirely, entirely in the same inner room with you, from where I stand.
Letter 372 — Lou to Anna, February 1933 · Volume 2
Affection remains strong, but disagreement becomes part of their companionship. A substantive exchange in 1927 records Anna’s resistance to Lou’s interpretation and Lou’s reply. The letters also illuminate Anna’s teaching, supervision, clinical associates and editorial work, including the child-observation publication planned with Rank and others but ultimately abandoned.
Edith Between Anna and Lou
Edith Rischawy had known Anna Freud since adolescence and was one of her close friends. In 1924, Anna helped arrange for Edith to be analyzed by Lou. Anna herself returned to analysis with her father at almost the same time.
The coincidence is extraordinary because both women were struggling with beating fantasies. Anna told Lou about the return of her daydreams, their connection to masturbation, and her reasons for seeking further analysis. Lou, meanwhile, was treating Edith for difficulties in which she believed masochism and beating fantasies were central.
On 23 April 1924, as Edith prepared to travel to Göttingen, Anna wrote:
“With Edith, a whole piece of me travels to you.”
—Anna to Lou, 23 April 1924, Letter 167. Translation from the German.
This wasn't simply a referral. Anna described Edith as part of herself, someone whose presence would connect her more closely to Lou. On 30 June she called Edith another little connecting piece leading toward Lou.
But the new arrangement also gave Edith an experience of Lou that Anna didn't possess.
On 21 June, Lou had disclosed Edith’s beating fantasies to Anna, explicitly stating that she was doing so without Edith’s knowledge. That was a breach of confidentiality. It also meant that Anna was receiving privileged information about Edith's relationship with Lou while Edith was undergoing her own private encounter with the analyst.
Anna's feelings became more complicated when Edith returned to Vienna that November. She'd expected Edith to bring some of Lou back with her. Instead, Anna felt that Edith had encountered a Lou she didn't recognize.
“As if she'd met a different Lou from the one I know.”
—Anna to Lou, 16 November 1924, Letter 202. Translation from the German.
The observation is a remarkable acknowledgment that the person Anna loved could be known differently by someone else. There were now three relationships: Anna with Edith, Edith with Lou, and Anna with Lou. Each woman knew something about the others, but no one could inhabit the other two relationships.
The question of who was entitled to know what remained complicated. On 6 January 1925, Lou withheld a sensitive detail because she wasn't sure Edith wanted Anna to know. Later that month Anna reported that Edith had given general permission for them to discuss her. Yet in the same letter Anna confided to Lou that she'd resumed analysis with her father and hadn't told Edith—or anyone else.
Even between close friends, privacy was uneven.
In 1925 Lou suggested that Anna take over Edith’s analysis. Anna resisted because she had known Edith too long and couldn't easily put aside her prior judgments. She later offered to analyze her under formal conditions, but Edith refused. Edith's decision preserved a boundary that both women had been struggling to define.
Their discussions of Edith also exposed expectations about women’s sexual lives. Lou worried that analysis might awaken Edith's sensuality without making heterosexual fulfillment available to her. Anna challenged Lou's belief that men didn't want Edith, particularly her assessment of Hans Lampl. Their own affection was meanwhile being expressed through letters, imagined visits, gifts, and intense declarations of love.
The contrast matters. Anna and Lou could recognize an extraordinarily rich emotional life between women while imagining a rather different sexual future as the proper goal for Edith.
The three-person problem returned in 1926. After Edith was distressed during a visit to Anna, Lou interpreted her unhappiness as involving fears about her relationship with Anna.
Then, in 1927, Edith surfaced in a conflict between Anna and Lou themselves. Anna had been hurt by Lou’s interpretation of her questions about her book on child analysis. She didn't want Lou to diagnose insecurity where Anna believed she'd been asking a genuine intellectual question. She reminded Lou how precious it had been to feel loved for who she was, rather than for what someone wanted her to be.
Then she asked:
“Or has Edith told you all sorts of silly things about me?”
—Anna to Lou, 30 November 1927, Letter 303. Translation from the German.
The question tells us that Anna feared Lou might be understanding her through someone else's account. That brings the earlier correspondence into focus. In 1924, Anna sent a piece of herself to Lou in the person of Edith. By November, she was discovering that Edith knew a different Lou. Three years later, while insisting on being understood in her own terms, she wondered whether Edith had helped produce Lou's mistaken picture of her.
Anna's resistance to interpretation wasn't simply a rejection of Lou's influence. She wanted their relationship to become one in which she could speak as an equal, be disagreed with, and still be recognized as herself.
Sources: Anna–Lou correspondence, Volume 1, Letters 167 (23 April 1924), 170 (5 May 1924), 177 (21 June 1924), 178 (30 June 1924), 202 (16 November 1924), 209 (6 January 1925), 211 (24 January 1925), 219–220 (February–March 1925); Volume 2, Letters 236–238 (June 1925), 286 (19 November 1926), 303 (30 November 1927), and 306 (11 December 1927).
Read the full Boundaries account · Explore Edith’s Atlas record
The later correspondence places professional obligations beside ordinary domestic decisions. On 22 October 1931 Anna told Lou about buying the Hochrotherd farmhouse with Dorothy Burlingham.
Thinking and writing together
Anna and Lou’s correspondence records a relationship through which ideas took shape. They discussed daydreams, fiction, and the movement from private fantasy into writing for another person. In her 1922 lecture, “Beating Fantasies and Daydreams,” Anna explicitly acknowledged their joint conversations. Leyrer reads the lecture as an intellectual initiative developed within their friendship: Anna extended her father’s account by examining how imaginative pleasure could become communication, authorship, and a relationship with a reader. Lou was a companion in that thinking and someone to whom Anna addressed her writing.
Their closeness continued through the material objects they exchanged. Anna made clothes for Lou, who described wearing them as an experience of Anna’s presence. In a letter of 5 June 1924, Lou took shelter from the cold in a knitted dress Anna had made. Writing from within its warmth, she told Anna:
“As I sit and write in it, I am, so to speak, sitting in you, and feel I need only speak.”
Lou to Anna, Letter 175, 5 June 1924, vol. 1. Translation from the German.
The dress gave a body to speech that distance interrupted. Anna’s work could be worn against Lou’s skin. Affection, bodily imagination, and intellectual companionship developed together.
Their language of sisterhood offered another form of belonging. Anna could remain Freud’s daughter and heir while becoming Lou’s friend, reader, and colleague. Lou also used sibling language for her male lovers: she described her sexual union with Rainer Maria Rilke through the image of brother and sister, and wrote of her lover Viktor Tausk as “Brother-animal. You.” For Lou, familial and erotic feeling could inhabit the same bond.
Sources: Lou Andreas-Salomé–Anna Freud correspondence, vol. 1, Letter 175; Anna Leyrer, “Thinking Together, Writing Apart” (2025), especially pp. 345–349 and 353–356; Lou Andreas-Salomé, Lebensrückblick, “Mit Rainer,” addendum of 1934; Lisa Appignanesi and John Forrester, Freud’s Women (1992).
Volume 1 — Rothe and Weber, revised 2003 edition: full source citation ↗
Volume 2 — Rothe and Weber, revised 2003 edition: full source citation ↗
Sigmund Freud and Anna Freud: affection, authority and exile
These father–daughter letters trace a changing relationship: childhood longing for time together, shared excursions, household affection, and finally the work of two psychoanalysts during illness and forced migration. Anna’s growing professional and practical authority belongs at the center of the story, even as her father’s stature shaped their exchanges.
A daughter’s voice, not just a famous father’s
On 7 July 1908 Freud imagined joining Anna for summer walks and swimming; in her letter of 13 July 1910, Anna wrote about separation, books, health and her wish for a journey alone with him. The 1923 Rome diary, published as an appendix, adds a shared travel experience. These passages record everyday tenderness, Anna’s interests, and their shared travel. Letters 3 SF and 6 AF; Rome diary appendix.
Anna’s disagreement and the longer analytic chronology
On 5 January 1913, before their formal analytic relationship began, Freud proposed that Anna’s intermittent illness reflected jealousy surrounding her sister Sophie’s marriage. In her reply of 7 January, seventeen-year-old Anna expressly disputed this explanation and denied keeping secrets. Anna expressly challenged her father’s interpretation. Letters 25 SF and 26 AF.
On 24 July 1919, Anna told her father that she had disclosed being in analysis with him to Margarete Rie because the friend had talked about her own therapy. An editorial note to July 1929 letter 261 SF separately documents a request for follow-up analysis after the Oxford congress and later work at Tegel. The two principal courses remain 1918–1922 and 1924–1925; later letters describe episodic follow-up. Letter 96 AF; note to 261 SF. Read the expanded Boundaries account.
Family closeness and analytic authority
Because father and daughter ordinarily lived together, their surviving correspondence is intermittent. Alongside family logistics, the edition traces Anna’s emergence as an analyst and her place in teaching, publishing and international organizational work. Related correspondence and editorial notes document Anna’s analysis with her father in 1918 and again in 1924.
In letter 287 SF, 3 September 1932, Freud reported to Anna his troubled reaction to Ferenczi’s paper before the Wiesbaden Congress, mixing theoretical objection, a question of professional leadership and private judgment. His characterization of Ferenczi belongs to Freud; it isn’t a retrospective diagnosis. Read the related Boundaries account.
Leaving Vienna, working from London
After the family fled Nazi-ruled Vienna in 1938, Anna undertook organizational work amid her father’s illness. Freud’s letters of 30 July–1 August 1938 reached her at the Paris psychoanalytic congress, where she presented an excerpt from his work on Moses. Money, doctors, travel, relatives, heat and professional obligations appear together. The printed letters and the editor’s account of emigration are different evidentiary layers. Letters 296–298 SF.
What survives in this edition
Ingeborg Meyer-Palmedo’s edition supplies chronological letters, contextual notes and appendices, including travel material; she checked uncertain photocopy readings against originals where accessible. Some items remain missing or inaccessible. After September 1930 no letters from Anna appear in the surviving published correspondence, and the editor counts only a small group of later letters, all from Freud. This is a rich but uneven archive.
Freud–Anna, Correspondence 1904–1938 (Polity, 2014) — full source citation ↗
Michael Schröter’s French edition of the Freud–Eitingon correspondence, translated by Olivier Mannoni and published by Hachette Littératures in 2009, contains 821 numbered documents and fourteen separately identified appendices. Letters, quotations from collateral correspondence, unsent drafts and editorial notes are distinct forms of evidence; the editor’s identifications aren’t represented as direct statements from a participant.
Their exchange joins the 1909 period of personal analysis, sustained clinical and publishing collaboration, the development of the Berlin Polyclinic, gifts, hospitality, financial support and institutional disagreement. Freud addressed Max as a chosen son and also interpreted his motives; Max retained his own judgments about work, care and boundaries. The letters record reciprocal affection alongside Freud’s analytic and institutional authority.
The genealogy separates actual analyses from suggestions of treatment or rejected referrals. Mirra Eitingon’s paid and domestic work, the contributions of Berlin clinic staff, and the experiences of analysts and patients in a shared circle are recorded in their own right.
Specific episodes complicate the story of a loyal institutional lieutenant: the Nacht family’s changing treatment arrangements, contested referrals and refusals, the financing of publishing and relief, and the clinical autonomy of Berlin staff. Mirra Eitingon’s illness, work and decisions belong in her own account. In private letters, Freud’s clinical interpretations of patients and colleagues entered professional decision-making.
The French correspondence edition — source and citation details
Freud and Oskar Pfister: faith, therapy and the human bond
The friendship between a secular psychoanalyst and a Swiss pastor turns questions of belief into practical questions of clinical care: how much authority an analyst should exercise, how treatment ends, and what kind of human relationship can remain. Their arguments coexist with warmth, professional cooperation and family news.
What survives in the 1963 edition
Psycho-Analysis and Faith, edited by Heinrich Meng and Ernst L. Freud and translated by Eric Mosbacher, presents selected letters exchanged between the two men. Its main sequence runs from 18 January 1909 to 12 March 1938, with 99 Freud-to-Pfister items, 30 Pfister-to-Freud items, and one separately identified collateral letter to Martha Freud in 1939. Lost or omitted letters, reconstruction of Pfister’s side and editorial choices—including a condition concerning living persons—affect what can be concluded from the surviving record.
Transference, independence and responsibility
- In October 1927 Pfister asked whether treatment could give way to a genuine human relation once transference had been analyzed. Freud’s answer emphasized independence and careful working-through, but rejected a lifeless technical distance and allowed a cordial relation afterward. Neither position makes the analyst indispensable by default.
- The anonymized A.B. case moves from proposed referrals and conditional arrangements to Freud’s attested ongoing treatment by October 1925. Freud described his disclosures to the patient’s parents and a private reason for not ending treatment.
Swiss colleagues, family and cross-disciplinary work
- Pfister’s exchange with Hermann Rorschach concerned test material, clinical assessment and publication after Rorschach’s death. Other contacts brought translation, pedagogical work and clergy into the analytic circle; the identification and nationality of a bishop described in the 1934 letters remain partly inconsistent across text and notes.
- Freud’s 1929 condolence marks the death of Pfister’s first wife, Erika Wunderli. The editors also identify his second wife, Martha Zuppinger-Urner. The correspondence follows Pfister’s marriages and family life alongside his discussion of clinical and personal relationships.
Freud–Pfister, Psycho-Analysis and Faith (Hogarth Press, 1963) — source citation ↗. A letter’s own statement is distinguished from the editors’ reconstruction of missing correspondence.
Freud and Jeanne Lampl-de Groot
Jeanne Lampl-de Groot appears as Freud’s analysand, colleague and intellectually independent interlocutor. The surviving letters trace clinical training, disagreements about female development and the building of a career beyond Vienna.
The surviving collection includes 76 numbered letters and postcards from Freud, four separately identified retrospective memoranda by Jeanne, selected extracts from Jeanne’s letters to her parents, and editorial notes. Gertie Bögels’s 2023 English edition, translated by Kenneth Kronenberg, distinguishes these sources and describes conflicting accounts of when Jeanne’s letters to Freud were destroyed.
Jeanne began analysis with Freud in April 1922, returned at distinct periods, and entered a circle of professional writing, clinical teaching and family friendship. Her papers prompted substantive arguments about female development. Freud welcomed her criticism, sometimes reconsidered his position, and asked for her help reading drafts. Jeanne returned to analysis in separate periods.
Her parental letters preserve an independent, sometimes critical account of Viennese training and social life. Later editorial notes illuminate her Dutch work and exile; those reconstructions aren’t treated as Freud’s own words. Read the separate analysis, mentorship, collaboration and influence links in the network to distinguish forms of authority and intellectual exchange.
Jeanne’s career wasn’t created by Freud alone. The edition identifies earlier learning with Siegfried Bernfeld, psychiatric training under Julius Wagner-Jauregg, and Eduard Hitschmann’s referral role. Her later translation work with Martin Lampl-de Groot carried psychoanalytic texts into Dutch. Separating these teaching, clinical and publishing relationships makes her independent contribution visible across clinical and professional relationships.
Freud’s correspondence with Jeanne Lampl-de Groot — 2023 source edition
Freud and Jung: correspondence, intimacy and authority
The letters trace affection, disagreements, clinical work and institutional obligations through Freud and Jung’s scientific partnership and rupture. The collection also preserves Emma Jung’s distinct correspondence and the work of Sabina Spielrein and other colleagues.
Scientific collaboration and the personal relationship
- Freud and Jung exchanged association research, technical interpretations, publishing labor and the contested language of fathers, sons and heirs. Their exchanges included informal interpretation of dreams and personal experiences.
- In a letter of 28 October 1907, Jung described his veneration as having an erotic undertone. The directed attachment records Jung’s own statement of erotic feeling.
- Their gradual rupture includes an apparently unsent December 1912 draft, crossing letters in January 1913, and later resignations from the Jahrbuch and international presidency. The theoretical disagreements and institutional obligations were real even as the personal relationship deteriorated.
Women’s intellectual work and clinical authority
- Sabina Spielrein’s research on destruction and transformation circulated in 1911–12, with Jung’s explicit acknowledgment of her biological thinking. The 1909 complaint records Jung’s withdrawal of allegations and Freud’s changing response. Spielrein’s diaries and correspondence preserve her perspective on the conflict.
- Emma Jung organized congress work and wrote to Freud in her own voice. Analysis within the marriage and the difficulty of the analyst’s objectivity require different attribution from later Toni Wolff events.
- Otto Gross’s Burghölzli treatment involved mutual interpretation, contested clinical assessments, disclosure and disputes over intellectual credit. Honegger undertook original research alongside his work with Jung.
Institutions, editorial choices and dissent
Bleuler’s objections, the staged Adler departures and disagreements over journals and association offices show that organizational decisions weren’t simply extensions of Freud and Jung’s private quarrel. The correspondence also preserves disputes about privacy and literary-source permission, including the question of Schreber’s consent. The letters report claims and choices made at the time; their authors’ judgments, including prejudiced ones, aren’t neutral diagnoses.
Freud–Jung correspondence, verified Princeton University Press edition ↗. References distinguish the dated letters, Emma Jung’s own letters, unsent drafts and editorial notes.
Freud and Otto Rank: dependence, originality and separation
Rank was much more than Freud’s secretary or the author of one contested theory. He edited, managed publishing work, practiced analysis and developed ideas with colleagues before the partnership unraveled. The letters show a prolonged negotiation over loyalty, criticism, money, clinical authority and intellectual independence—not a clean break on one date.
A colleague with clinical and editorial authority
- Rank’s early service to Freud opened educational and publishing opportunities, but he also exercised judgment. By 1921 Freud was describing Rank’s daily analytic hours; later letters record active treatment work. The editors also discuss an earlier 1919 commencement reported in later sources.
- His work with Hanns Sachs on Imago, with Sándor Ferenczi on The Development of Psycho-Analysis, and with publishers and translators reveals a distributed intellectual enterprise. A proposed title or payment arrangement isn’t proof that it was carried out.
How the disagreement developed
Arguments about Rank’s birth-trauma theory and the joint work with Ferenczi intensified through 1924–1926. The correspondence records praise, criticism, attempts at accommodation, practical publishing disputes and conflicting reports of personal loyalty. Financial support, salaries, loans, gifts, publication rights and editorial credit were distinct parts of the conflict.
Rank’s theory, offices and reconciliation preserves the chronology of these differing positions.
Women’s work and testimony beyond the principal letters
- Beata Rank worked on translation and family publishing arrangements; Freud’s favorable encouragement and later hostile judgments of her influence are separate, attributed positions. The editors report analytic sessions with Freud in January 1926. An analysis with Ferenczi had been proposed in 1925.
- Caroline Newton connected analyses and translation work; Jessie Taft received analysis from Rank in 1926 and developed his ideas in social work with Virginia Robinson, her professional and domestic partner.
- Anaïs Nin’s later diary records pleasure and relief as well as the overlap of treatment, intimacy and apprenticeship. Her diary, Beata’s recollections and other later testimony aren’t themselves Freud–Rank letters.
How to read this edition
The 2012 Lieberman–Kramer edition combines surviving correspondence, appendices, editorial narrative and later testimony. Its main and appendix letters are unnumbered; their computer codes are editorial date identifiers, and some salutations and closings are omitted in the appendix. The 1930 removal of Rank’s honorary association membership is reported in the editorial material, but isn’t evidence of a statutory ban on his practicing therapy. Each layer of testimony has to be read on its own terms.
Freud–Rank, Inside Psychoanalysis (Johns Hopkins, 2012) — source citation ↗. Edited by E. James Lieberman and Robert Kramer; translated by Gregory C. Richter.
Wilhelm Reich and A. S. Neill: friendship, freedom and disagreement
Reich and the Summerhill educator A. S. Neill sustained a friendship rooted in questions about children, sexual repression and freedom. Their letters carry warmth, intellectual companionship and strong disagreement across twenty-one years. They also reveal the practical tensions when friendship overlaps with treatment, school authority and claims about bodily health.
Shared questions and an enduring attachment
They met in Oslo in 1936 after Neill encountered Reich’s writing on fascism. They exchanged books, educational reflections, political fears, translation hopes and affection while living increasingly far apart. Later they disagreed about Reich’s scientific and political interpretations; a bitter exchange in 1956 didn’t end Neill’s concern for his friend before Reich’s death in 1957.
When the friend was also the doctor
In November 1937 Reich reserved an hour each day for Neill’s planned Oslo visit. The editor estimates ten to twelve treatment sessions during the subsequent stay; in February–March 1938 Neill reported his response, while Reich cautioned against treating a few weeks as a cure. Neill described this personal treatment in the correspondence.
Earlier, on 22 March 1936, Neill asked Reich to see a Summerhill parent after he found he couldn’t proceed with his own attempted analysis. Reich’s reply discussed information and fees; a December letter confirms that the parent was later in treatment. Read the referral and boundary account.
Children and the limits of a proposed intervention
In March 1938 Neill asked whether a breathing exercise associated with Reich’s approach might help young boys who wet the bed. Reich admitted his lack of experience with that work in children and warned against forcing it or triggering severe bodily reactions. Read the related Boundaries account.
Neill’s earlier analysts and changing clinical practice
In a letter of 30 August 1944, Neill called the American educator Homer Lane his first analyst. Placzek’s introduction says Lane offered treatment without charge and Neill accepted, while later doubting its effect. An editorial note to Neill’s 6 May 1938 letter identifies a separate few weeks as a patient of Wilhelm Stekel. The genealogy records these courses of treatment with Lane and Stekel. Introduction; 6 May 1938; 30 August 1944.
Neill wrote in July 1941 that he couldn’t bring himself to conduct individual analysis. In May–July 1944 he described renewed body-oriented work with adolescents, including four girls and four boys, while serving as their headmaster. In November 1945 he reported that the adolescents had gradually ceased attending. Read the 1944–1945 Boundaries account. The earlier 1938 discussion concerned a separate proposal for two boys. 1 July 1941; 22 May 1944; 15 July 1944; 28 November 1945.
Children and orgone devices: reported practice and claimed effects
In August 1944, Reich reported that he and Ilse placed infant Peter in an orgone accumulator briefly each day; he speculated that this helped the child and urged Neill to acquire smaller devices for pupils. Neill replied that wartime shortages prevented him obtaining one. The correspondence preserves participants’ reports about the device and its effects. 6 and 30 August 1944.
On 4 April 1947, Neill reported acquiring an accumulator and said that baby Zoe used it with her mother Ena. He proposed trials of the device for schoolchildren’s ailments. This later context belongs in Genealogy; the Boundaries accounts stop at 1945. 4 April 1947.
What the published letters can establish
Beverley R. Placzek’s 1981 edition covers 1936–1957, but it isn’t a complete transcript of all exchanged letters. It derives from Reich’s surviving file: most of Neill’s letters remain, while many of Reich’s outgoing letters are missing. The editor abridged repetition and parts of Neill’s descriptions of health. Later letters document loyalty and disagreement, but Reich presented his scientific claims within the exchange. The Boundaries accounts on this site stop at 1945, while this correspondence summary follows the friendship through 1957.
Reich–Neill, Record of a Friendship (Farrar, Straus and Giroux, 1981) — full source citation ↗
Freud, Ferenczi, and the Budapest circle
Three volumes follow the formation of the network, analysis and intimate relationships, scientific collaboration, clinical experiments, and institutional conflict. Women, patients, colleagues and patrons connect the Budapest circle to Vienna, Berlin, Britain and the United States.
1908–1914 · Forming the network Volume 1
1914–1919 · War, marriage and analytic work Volume 2
- Gizella Pálos and Elma Pálos: the earlier treatment network in Ferenczi, Elma, and Freud leads into Freud’s analysis of Ferenczi and his interventions in the marriage decision. Gizella also read and discussed psychoanalytic work.
- Anton von Freund, Rózsi von Freund, and Hugo Dubovitz: Margit Dubovitz’s treatment, marriage, and relationship with Anton brought Freud and Ferenczi into a network of patients and spouses.
- Erzsébet Révész and Sándor Radó: the letters place her treatment of him alongside their intended marriage. Freud’s analysis of Anna also appears directly in the correspondence.
- Ferenczi’s account of a young woman’s treatment and death: a kiss, literary assistance, a delayed resumption of analysis, and the private exchange with Freud that followed.
- The early active technique: Ferenczi’s instructions about a patient’s bodily habits and Freud’s encouragement of clinical experiment.
- Géza Dukes and a proposed transfer to Freud; the commandant’s analysis on horseback; István Hollós’s brief analysis with Freud.
- Jones, analysis, and theoretical disagreement: Freud and Ferenczi interpreted an intellectual dispute through what they believed they knew of Jones as a patient.
- Anton von Freund as patient and patron: personal treatment intersected with plans to fund psychoanalytic publishing and teaching.
- Rózsi von Freund and The Taboo of Virginity: the private clinical source and the discussion of its proposed subtitle.
- Aranka Schwarcz, patient and wartime courier; Miksa Schächter, Ferenczi’s medical and intellectual mentor. The wider records distinguish analysis, other treatment, mentorship, and collaboration.
1920–1933 · Technique, confidence and institutions Volume 3
- Eugenia Sokolnicka’s criticism, analytic work and attachment to Rank; Rózsi’s further analysis; Kata Lévy’s clinical consultation; and Margit Dubovitz’s direction of child guidance expand the women’s professional histories.
- Blumenthal’s concealed referral warning, Inman’s confidential letter, and Franklin and Urbantschitsch’s private assessments trace information that patients and trainees didn’t know was being exchanged.
- The Burlingham household brings Amsden’s conflicting treatment obligations together with Izette de Forest’s analysis by Ferenczi and Judy de Forest’s analysis by Anna Freud.
- Feldmann’s forced departure, the Wolf Man’s recollection in the dispute with Rank, and Reich’s article and editorial control show clinical confidence entering institutional decisions.
- The unfinished Freud–Ferenczi analysis, the full 1931 dispute over kissing, and Severn’s testimony place mutuality, restraint and the analyst’s desires within the history of technique.
- The Budapest clinic’s premises, permission and financial support and Alexander’s uncertain Chicago position in 1931 connect the letters to institutions. The clinic’s July and December opening dates are attributed to their differing sources.
- Ferenczi’s presidency decision and publication dispute distinguish the request for delay, his Wiesbaden presentation and the later English publication decision. His final letters with Freud preserve continuing concern and the disagreement about emigration.
Freud–Ferenczi correspondence: Volume 1 · Volume 2 · Volume 3
Abraham and the Berlin circle
The complete correspondence follows the formation of the Berlin network through treatment, teaching, family contact, and professional disagreement. It adds missing analytic connections and shows how private clinical reports entered the movement’s decisions.
Patients, teachers, and families Follow the connections
Clinical confidence and professional power Read the accounts
Loyalty and disagreement Beyond the consulting room
Freud–Abraham correspondence ↗
The Stracheys between London and Berlin
James and Alix’s correspondence connects analysis, marriage, clinical discussion, translation, and the practical work of making an analytic community. Their letters follow people between consulting rooms, households, lecture rooms, and institutions.
Analysts, patients, and private knowledge Treatment and friendship
Translation, teaching, and institutional authority The work of the circle
Strachey correspondence ↗
Sigmund Freud and Lou Andreas-Salomé: love and intellectual intimacy
Sigmund Freud and Lou Andreas-Salomé’s correspondence records a loving friendship sustained through intellectual discovery, personal recognition, and concern for each other’s lives. Their exchanges move between theory and clinical work, family and money, illness and the wish to be together. Love belongs to their own description of the relationship. Freud tells Lou that he loves her; Lou asks for complete openness between them and writes of her longing to see him.
Lou was also the person to whom Freud confessed his divided wishes about Anna. Across letters from July 1922 to May 1925 he recognized his own part in Anna’s inhibited independence: wanting her to form relationships beyond the family, while dreading the loss of her closeness. Their letters place paternal attachment and clinical authority within the same relationship. Some passages survive in Gay’s use of the Library of Congress correspondence rather than the selective published Freud–Lou volume. Gay (1989).
Presence and understanding
During Lou’s period of study in Vienna, Freud already singled out her presence among his listeners. On 10 November 1912, he described looking toward the place reserved for her during his lecture:
“I have adopted the bad habit of always directing my lecture to a definite member of the audience, and yesterday I fixed my gaze as if spellbound at the place which had been kept for you.”
Sigmund to Lou, 10 November 1912.
Lou wanted to know that their personal connection was welcomed on both sides. In February 1913, concerned that he might be giving her his time merely out of politeness, she asked for a relationship whose openness could continue beyond her stay in Vienna:
“Please allow me, whether I am here or elsewhere, whether this winter in Vienna is continued or not, to enjoy a relationship of complete openness and immediacy with you, and to be sure that that is how you wish it.”
Lou to Sigmund, 27 February 1913.
Freud answered by describing what her understanding gave him—and the apprehension of having to do without it:
“You spoil people like me, who are continually tempted to complain about mankind, by a degree of understanding which extends beyond what has been said, so that one then becomes apprehensive of being spoilt too much, lest one should have to suffer subsequent deprivation.”
Sigmund to Lou, 2 March 1913.
He hoped to see and talk with her often before she left. The exchange gives their intellectual affinity an emotional life. Lou asks for directness and the assurance that their closeness is mutually desired. Freud acknowledges the pleasure of being understood and imagines the loss her departure might bring.
That intimacy continued in their work. Freud welcomed her elaboration of his thinking as an amplification and improvement of his ideas. When he suggested that her book of thanks should name psychoanalysis rather than himself, Lou defended the personal dedication: her experience of the person and her experience of the knowledge belonged together. Their intellectual exchange carried gratitude and attachment. Letters.
Love, longing, and care
In April 1931, Freud reproached Lou affectionately for allowing her seventieth birthday to pass without telling him. He wanted the opportunity to say explicitly what she meant to him:
“Perhaps I should have been glad of the chance of saying to you on your birthday how greatly I esteem and love you.”
Sigmund to Lou, 3 April 1931.
Two years later, Lou expressed the urgency of her wish to be with him:
“Yes, simply to get away, straightaway, to be able to spend just one day with you—never have I so ardently desired it before.”
Lou to Sigmund, 6 May 1933.
Their later letters make the wish for physical presence especially poignant. Sending a photograph in May 1935, Lou imagined what she wanted in its place:
“If only instead of that I could look for just ten minutes into your face—into the father-face which has presided over my life.”
Lou to Sigmund, 4 May 1935.
The longing and the familial image occupy the same sentence. Lou gives Freud a paternal place in her emotional life while expressing an immediate wish to look at him and be near him. Her use of family language needs to be understood within her wider vocabulary of attachment, which could bring familial and erotic feeling together.
In Freud’s Women, Appignanesi and Forrester describe “the aura, if never the fact, of a love affair between them.” The correspondence gives that observation a personal texture: the pleasure of being understood, affectionate reproach, explicit love, concern for one another’s health, and repeated wishes to overcome distance. Freud’s Women.
Alongside Anna and Lou’s relationship
Alongside her attachment to Sigmund, Lou developed a distinct friendship and intellectual collaboration with Anna Freud. Sigmund encouraged their acquaintance, but the women gave their relationship purposes of their own. Anna credited their joint conversations in her 1922 lecture, “Beating Fantasies and Daydreams.” Anna Leyrer reads this collaboration as a setting in which Anna could develop her own account of fantasy and creative work, finding recognition in a friend and reader while remaining deeply attached to her father.
Lou’s relationships with Sigmund and Anna intersected through visits, letters, shared work, and the language of family. Each also had its own emotional and intellectual history. Reading the two correspondences together makes room for Sigmund and Lou’s loving friendship and for the intimacy through which Anna and Lou thought, wrote, and imagined being together.
Primary source: Sigmund Freud and Lou Andreas-Salomé: Letters, edited by Ernst Pfeiffer, translated by William and Elaine Robson-Scott (1972). Further reading: Appignanesi and Forrester, Freud’s Women (1992); Anna Leyrer, “Thinking Together, Writing Apart” (2025), pp. 343–350 and 353–356.
Lou’s work as analyst and colleague Clinical and intellectual ties
Affection, households, and intellectual companionship Shared lives
Clinical intimacy, money, and responsibility Accounts in Boundaries
Freud–Andreas-Salomé letters ↗
Sigmund Freud and Marie Bonaparte
Sigmund Freud and Marie Bonaparte corresponded from 1925 to 1939. Their letters continued discussions from her analysis and developed questions about female sexuality, love affairs, family relationships, writing, illness, and the future of psychoanalysis. Bonaparte regarded Freud as both father and friend. She sent him personal accounts, theoretical work, manuscripts, photographs, and gifts for his collection of antiquities.
Records of analysis and daily life
Bonaparte also kept extensive records of her own life and analysis. Her papers at the Library of Congress include dream books covering 1924–1961, nine notebooks from her analysis with Freud in October and November 1925, five childhood notebooks with drawings, an autobiographical manuscript, and notes on the Freud–Fliess correspondence.
The final letters
In his last letter to Bonaparte, dated 16 June 1939, Freud wrote about his physical pain, the comfort he received from his dogs, and the sale of 1,800 copies of the German edition of Moses and Monotheism. Bonaparte continued writing during the summer. Her final, unsent letter, dated 23 September, joined concern for Freud’s illness with the war in Poland.
Clinical work, family letters, and publication
Agnes Sobolewska Alsberg, “Psychoanalysis and Biography in Times of Crisis” (2025), TC17 and TC25–TC27; Sobolewska, “Life for the Future” (2026a), pp. 19–20.