Skip to the chronology
History of Psychoanalysis

History of Psychoanalysis / Standards & consequences

Geographic scopeUnited
States

Rules:
Analytic Accountability

Professional standards, law, and enforcement.

Who could regulate a psychoanalyst, and what could happen when they intervened?

Professional standards · Public authorityExplore the timeline ↓Who can do what? ↓

From professional standing to public authority

One practice.
Several kinds of power.

Early institutes decided who could train, teach, and belong. State authorities decided who could legally practice. Courts could award damages or impose criminal sentences. Federal requirements later connected disciplinary records and established enforceable protections for patient information.

These systems developed alongside one another. A new code, an allegation, a finding, and a penalty each mark a different moment. The timeline follows those distinctions through actual cases and dated institutional changes.

01 / The powers

Who can do what?

Membership, permission to practice, and liability are separate matters. The same conduct can fall within more than one authority’s jurisdiction.

AuthorityWhat it controlsPossible consequence
Analytic instituteTraining, supervision, and institutional rolesLose teaching, training, or leadership responsibilities
Professional associationMembership and professional standingCensure, suspension, or expulsion
State licensing boardLegal authorization under a license or registrationConditions, restrictions, suspension, or revocation
Civil courtLiability for actionable injuryDamages payable to a patient
Criminal courtCriminal offenses proved in prosecutionA criminal sentence under the applicable law
Federal agencies & courtsApplicable federal duties and legal claimsReporting duties, corrective measures, penalties, or court orders

Association and institute procedures govern their members; state boards govern the relevant license or registration. Federal obligations apply according to the particular law. [7] [11] [32] [28]

“Expelled—but could he still practice?”

Expulsion removes membership. Legal authority to practice depends on the practitioner’s state license, registration, or other lawful authorization. A board can investigate the same conduct and impose its own restrictions.

02 / Follow the development

Five parallel histories

Compare the decades across five authorities, or read the events in date order. Select an event for the account, outcome, jurisdiction, and sources.

Rule / frameworkJudicial rulingConsequenceProceedingInstitutional response

Decades run left to right. Rows identify the principal authority; the event account explains any connection to another system. Blank cells contain no selected event.

The chronology

1934Criminal lawA prosecution for unauthorized practiceNew York imposes a fine and a suspended sentence on May Benzenberg Mayer.Conviction & sentence

Mayer, a teacher associated with psychoanalysis and esoteric philosophy, was prosecuted after a former student paid for treatment through dream analysis. Library of Congress archivists record a conviction under New York’s Medical Practice Act. [19] [12]

Consequence
A $500 fine and a one-year suspended sentence.
Jurisdiction
New York; unauthorized medical practice.
Link to this event ↗
1938Institutes & associationsMembership defined through medical qualificationsAPsA reserves membership to physicians with approved psychiatric residency training.Membership rule

Hale describes rules tying professional recognition to medical qualifications and approved training. These requirements shaped admission to the organized analytic profession. Young-Bruehl and Dunbar place the American medical restriction within the larger struggle over who could train and belong, connecting it with the later legal challenge and widening access to analytic institutions. [12] [34]

Effect
Access to membership depended on the prescribed qualifications.
Jurisdiction
American Psychoanalytic Association.
Link to this event ↗
1940Institutes & associationsCertification requires accepted Freudian instructionAPsA’s certification committee insists on instruction in basic Freudian psychoanalysis.Training requirement

Institutional recognition regulated theoretical preparation as well as professional credentials. Hale dates this insistence by the certification committee to 1940. [12]

Effect
Training standards linked certification to a defined theoretical curriculum.
Jurisdiction
American Psychoanalytic Association.
Link to this event ↗
May 22, 1941State licensingCalifornia treats psychoanalysis as medical practiceAttorney General Earl Warren interprets medical licensing law to cover psychoanalysis, even when the practitioner charges no fee.Attorney general opinion

In opinion N835334, issued on May 22, 1941, Earl Warren interpreted California’s medical licensing law as prohibiting unlicensed psychoanalytic practice, paid or unpaid. Farber and Green describe the restrictions encountered by émigré analysts, including Otto Fenichel, whose European medical qualifications didn’t establish a California license. [22] [10]

Effect
Practitioners without California medical authorization couldn’t lawfully conduct psychoanalysis under Warren’s interpretation.
Jurisdiction
California; opinion of the attorney general on medical practice.

The Ninth Circuit recounted the 1941 opinion in its later review of California psychoanalytic licensing.

Fenichel on Genealogy

Link to this event ↗
May 13, 1944Institutes & associationsUnauthorized training reaches national committeesAPsA’s governing bodies meet over the boundaries of recognized training.Committee proceedings

The Council on Professional Training and the Executive Council considered the boundaries of recognized psychoanalytic training and the problem of unauthorized training.

Effect
Professional jurisdiction and who could train analysts became formal committee business.
Jurisdiction
APsA training and executive bodies.
Link to this event ↗
December 1953Institutes & associationsAPsA adopts a Code of EthicsA national code enters the association’s documented ethical framework.Code adopted

In 1953 the American Psychoanalytic Association adopted an ethics code that threatened suspension or expulsion for members conducting unauthorized training. Hale places the measure in the association’s effort to control training and recognition. [12]

Effect
A written association standard with committee machinery around it.
Jurisdiction
American Psychoanalytic Association.
Link to this event ↗
1958State licensingCalifornia regulates the title “psychologist”State certification begins by protecting a professional title.Title regulation

The Ninth Circuit’s later account distinguishes California’s 1958 certification legislation from its broader 1967 regulation of psychological practice. [22]

Effect
Use of the title becomes subject to state qualification requirements.
Jurisdiction
California psychology regulation.
Link to this event ↗
March 3, 1960Civil courtsAlleged violence in treatment reaches the courtsNew York’s highest court restores Alice Hammer’s malpractice claim for trial.Claim reinstated

Testimony described psychiatrist John Rosen beating Hammer during treatment. The court held that the alleged conduct could support a malpractice case without initial expert testimony. [13]

Ruling
The claim returns for trial.
Jurisdiction
New York Court of Appeals.
Link to this event ↗
May 1963Civil courtsTreatment entanglements lead to damagesAda Margaret Zipkin obtains a $17,000 judgment against psychiatrist Robert Freeman.Damages awarded

The treatment involved sexual, social, residential, and financial entanglements. The subsequent Missouri opinion records the jury’s damages award. [35]

Consequence
A $17,000 civil judgment.
Jurisdiction
Missouri; psychiatric malpractice.
Link to this event ↗
1967State licensingCalifornia extends regulation to practiceA licensing scheme replaces the earlier title-certification approach.Practice regulation

The 1967 legislation broadened governmental authority over psychological services, including practice relevant to psychoanalysis. [22]

Effect
Practitioners became subject to the licensing scheme and its exemptions.
Jurisdiction
California.
Link to this event ↗
December 31, 1968Civil courtsMalpractice coverage follows the treatment dutyMissouri’s Supreme Court holds that Freeman’s liability falls within his professional coverage.Coverage upheld

The insurance litigation addressed payment of Zipkin’s existing judgment. The court treated the injury as arising from failures in professional care. [35]

Ruling
The professional-liability policy covers the judgment.
Jurisdiction
Missouri Supreme Court.
Link to this event ↗
March 14, 1975Civil courtsSex presented as treatment becomes a malpractice claimA court allows Julie Roy’s claims against her psychiatrist to proceed.Claims allowed to proceed

Roy alleged that Renatus Hartogs prescribed sexual relations as psychiatric treatment. The court rejected his attempt to dismiss the action under a law abolishing seduction lawsuits. [26]

Ruling
Malpractice and assault claims survive the motion to dismiss.
Jurisdiction
Civil Court of the City of New York, Trial Term, New York County.
Link to this event ↗
December 1975Institutes & associationsAPsA publishes predecessor ethics principlesThe association’s current published code identifies December 1975 principles.Principles published

The code’s introduction identifies the 1975 publication and a later 1983 revision as predecessors to its revised standards. [2]

Effect
Successive written formulations of association ethics.
Jurisdiction
American Psychoanalytic Association.
Link to this event ↗
July 1, 1976Civil courtsA duty to protect a threatened personCalifornia’s Supreme Court recognizes a duty of reasonable care to protect an intended victim.Duty recognized

When a therapist determines, or professionally should determine, that a patient poses a serious danger of violence to another, the court requires reasonable care to protect that person. [29]

Ruling
A state-law duty that can require action beyond the consulting room.
Jurisdiction
California; other states developed their own rules.
Link to this event ↗
1983Institutes & associationsAPsA revises its ethics principlesA further stage of codification follows the 1975 principles.Principles revised

The association’s published code expressly records this revision in its account of earlier standards. [2]

Effect
The association’s written ethical framework is revised.
Jurisdiction
American Psychoanalytic Association.
Link to this event ↗
1985–1986 editionCriminal lawWisconsin defines a therapist-specific crimeThe operative statute makes sexual contact during an ongoing therapeutic relationship a felony.Criminal statute in force

The Wisconsin Supreme Court reproduces this statutory edition in Eichman. Its definition reaches people providing psychotherapy whether licensed or unlicensed; consent is excluded as an issue under the provision. [28]

Effect
A specific offense available for criminal prosecution.
Jurisdiction
Wisconsin Statutes § 940.22, 1985–1986 edition.
Link to this event ↗
August 1, 1986Civil courtsMinnesota creates a sexual-exploitation remedyA specific civil action addresses sexual exploitation in psychotherapy.Law effective

The 1986 act covers conduct during treatment and specified post-treatment encounters involving emotional dependence or therapeutic deception. It also defines circumstances for employer liability. [1]

Effect
Patients can seek statutory damages from therapists and, in specified circumstances, employers.
Jurisdiction
Minnesota; 1986 Laws, chapter 372.
Link to this event ↗
October 7, 1987State licensingMasserman surrenders his Illinois medical licenseA state consent order ends his authority to practice medicine or psychotherapy.License surrendered

After an Illinois investigation into former patients’ allegations, Jules H. Masserman signs a consent order surrendering his medical and controlled-substance licenses and his right to provide psychotherapy or psychoanalysis. He denies wrongdoing. The agreement is a regulatory consequence, not a court judgment resolving each accusation. [24] [21]

Consequence
Medical and controlled-substance licenses surrendered; right to practice medicine and psychotherapy relinquished.
Jurisdiction
Illinois Department of Registration and Education.

Noel and Watterson give the October 7 date and reproduce an account of the consent order. McCracken independently reports the surrender and denial.

Masserman’s earlier Chicago training and research

Link to this event ↗
1988Federal lawFederal litigation changes association accessAn antitrust settlement requires APsA to open psychoanalytic training to qualified nonmedical trainees.Antitrust settlement

Schechter describes the 1988 out-of-court settlement following the 1984 restraint-of-trade suit and its effect on the admission of nonmedical trainees. [27]

Consequence
Association admission policies change under an external legal settlement.
Jurisdiction
Federal antitrust litigation affecting APsA.
Link to this event ↗
February 17, 1988Criminal lawThe criminal statute is used in a prosecutionWisconsin charges Raymond Eichman with therapist sexual exploitation.Criminal charges

The 1990 Supreme Court opinion records the charges and reviews a pretrial evidentiary decision. It allows the prosecution’s challenge and returns the case to the trial court. [28]

Procedural outcome
Criminal proceedings and appellate review of an evidentiary ruling.
Jurisdiction
Wisconsin; State v. Eichman.
Link to this event ↗
1988Institutes & associationsPatient money costs a director his positionEthics proceedings lead to George Pollock’s removal from Chicago Institute leadership.Leadership removed

Schechter’s dissertation records proceedings over Pollock’s receipt of substantial sums from a wealthy patient and his ouster as director. Her account draws on a 2009 institutional retrospective involving participants. [27]

Consequence
Removal from the directorship.
Jurisdiction
Chicago Institute for Psychoanalysis; institutional response.
Link to this event ↗
September 1, 1990Federal lawDisciplinary information gains a national channelThe National Practitioner Data Bank links specified malpractice payments and adverse actions.Reporting system

The Health Care Quality Improvement Act of 1986 created the framework. NPDB’s reportable history begins in September 1990, providing information to authorized organizations. [14] [15]

Effect
Qualifying reports can inform credentialing and regulatory decisions across institutions.
Jurisdiction
Federal reporting system; coverage varies by reporting category and profession.
Link to this event ↗
1991Institutes & associationsPsychiatric associations suspend MassermanThe American Psychiatric Association Appeals Board votes for a five-year ethics suspension.Five-year suspension

Masserman, a former president of the American Psychiatric Association, is suspended from that organization and the Illinois Psychiatric Society for five years for violations of psychiatric medical ethics. These are psychiatric associations, not the American Psychoanalytic Association (APsA). The association’s disciplinary decision is distinct from the former patients’ civil allegations and settlements. [24] [21] [31]

Consequence
Five-year suspension from the American Psychiatric Association and Illinois Psychiatric Society.
Jurisdiction
American Psychiatric Association and Illinois Psychiatric Society.

McCracken reports the decision in 1991; the APA Board publicly confirmed the five-year suspension in 1992.

Link to this event ↗
May 1991Institutes & associationsSexual orientation removed as a basis for exclusionAPsA adopts a nondiscrimination policy on homosexuality, amended in May 1992.Nondiscrimination policy

In May 1991, the American Psychoanalytic Association adopted a nondiscrimination policy on homosexuality; it amended the statement in May 1992. Selection and advancement were to depend on qualifications relevant to analytic work. Putting that change into practice took further work. Roughton describes institute visits, guidance for evaluating applicants, and challenges to continuing discrimination. [4] [20]

Effect
Association policy required selection and advancement to rest on relevant qualifications rather than sexual orientation.
Jurisdiction
American Psychoanalytic Association and its affiliated training institutes.

Dates are confirmed in the association’s 2012 successor statement; the account of implementation is Ralph Roughton’s, in Lewes et al. (2008), pp. 312–315.

British context: Anna Freud and homosexual candidates

Link to this event ↗
September 20, 1992Institutes & associationsPatient pressure brings a psychiatric sanction into public viewAfter Barbara Noel’s book and Ann Landers’s column, APA trustees publicly name Masserman and confirm his suspension.Suspension named publicly

Noel’s 1992 book challenged the limited visibility of the professional sanction. Ann Landers’s September 13 column pressed the American Psychiatric Association to disclose its action. On September 20 its Board of Trustees authorized a statement naming Masserman, confirming the five-year suspension, and condemning his conduct. Psychiatric News published the statement on October 16. In the same issue, APA ethics officers explained that expulsions were routinely published, while public notice of suspensions had required separate authorization. [24] [31] [18]

Consequence
National public notice of the existing ethics suspension; the record doesn’t establish a new expulsion.
Jurisdiction
American Psychiatric Association; public statement reproduced in Psychiatric News.

The Board’s public statement was authorized on September 20 and appeared in print on October 16; these are different dates.

Link to this event ↗
June 13, 1996Federal lawA federal psychotherapist–patient privilegeThe Supreme Court protects confidential therapeutic communications in federal evidence law.Privilege recognized

Jaffee recognizes the privilege for psychotherapy, including treatment by licensed clinical social workers. [17]

Ruling
Protection against compelled disclosure in proceedings governed by federal privilege law.
Jurisdiction
United States Supreme Court.
Link to this event ↗
September 29, 2000State licensingPsychoanalysis remains subject to state licensingThe Ninth Circuit rejects constitutional challenges to California’s licensing scheme.Licensing upheld

The court holds that using speech in psychoanalytic treatment doesn’t exempt professional practice from state regulation. [22]

Ruling
California’s regulatory scheme survives the challenge.
Jurisdiction
Federal appellate review of California licensing.
Link to this event ↗
2002State licensingNew York establishes a psychoanalyst licenseLegislation creates psychoanalysis as a separately licensed profession.Profession established

The state’s later report dates the legislation to 2002. Licensing could begin in 2005; the requirement to be licensed or otherwise authorized took effect in 2006. [23]

Effect
A specific state licensing route for psychoanalysis.
Jurisdiction
New York; Laws of 2002, chapter 676.
Link to this event ↗
April 14, 2003Federal lawFederal privacy standards become operationalMost covered entities must comply with the HIPAA Privacy Rule.Compliance required

HIPAA’s 1996 legislation was followed by implementing rules. Covered providers acquired duties concerning patient information, with federal investigation and enforcement. [32]

Effect
Corrective action and civil penalties become available for covered violations.
Jurisdiction
Federal; applies to covered entities and relevant business associates.
Link to this event ↗
January 1, 2006State licensingNew York’s authorization requirement takes effectPsychoanalysts must hold the required license or another lawful authorization.Requirement effective

The implementation date gives the 2002 legislation its practical licensing threshold. Other qualifying professional licenses and legal exemptions remain part of the scheme. [23]

Effect
State authorization becomes a condition of lawful practice.
Jurisdiction
New York.
Link to this event ↗
June 15, 2006Institutes & associationsAn expulsion vote enters an appeal processAPsA’s Executive Council minutes record an ethics decision and the member’s appeal.Expulsion vote · appeal pending

The ethics committee voted to expel a member after reviewing two local society decisions. The Council approved an appeals committee as required by its procedures. [3]

Procedural status
A disciplinary decision followed by formal appellate review.
Jurisdiction
American Psychoanalytic Association.
Link to this event ↗
June 2010Institutes & associationsAn institute confronts the limits of its processA senior training analyst resigns memberships and retires his license amid a boundary crisis.Resignations / process stalled

Honig and Barron report that, with no complainant before the committee, no formal ethics proceeding occurred. The institute considered delaying acceptance of resignations to preserve time for information or a complaint to emerge. [16]

Effect
Voluntary departures and an institutional effort to repair its procedures.
Jurisdiction
An anonymized American institute case study.
Link to this event ↗
September 7, 2017Institutes & associationsAn explicit path from complaint to sanctionBPSI’s published procedures define investigation, hearings, sanctions, and appeal rights.Procedures published

Available measures range from corrective treatment or supervision to censure, suspension, and expulsion. [7]

Effect
A documented process for applying professional standards.
Jurisdiction
Boston Psychoanalytic Society and Institute.
Link to this event ↗
2023Federal lawOnline disclosures bring federal consequencesA psychiatric practice settles potential HIPAA violations over responses to online reviews.Settlement & corrective plan

Manasa Health Center agreed to pay HHS $30,000 and carry out a corrective-action plan after an investigation of patient-information disclosures. [33]

Settlement terms
Payment, policies, training, and compliance monitoring.
Jurisdiction
Federal HHS Office for Civil Rights; a covered psychiatric practice.
Link to this event ↗
January 1, 2025State licensingCalifornia transfers research-psychoanalyst oversightThe registration program moves from the Medical Board to the Board of Psychology.Oversight transferred

SB 815 changes the state body responsible for research psychoanalysts and student research psychoanalysts. [8]

Effect
Registration and oversight move to the Board of Psychology.
Jurisdiction
California research-psychoanalyst registration category.
Link to this event ↗
January 1, 2026State licensingAssociation ethics enters state enforcementCalifornia directs its board to use APsA ethics as the standard for psychoanalysis.Law effective

Section 2954.6 requires the APsA Code of Ethics to inform registration examinations, enforcement policies, and disciplinary evaluations. [9]

Effect
A professional code becomes a state enforcement standard for registrants.
Jurisdiction
California research-psychoanalyst registration category.
Link to this event ↗
January 13, 2026Institutes & associationsAPsA reports approval of an ethics-code revisionA presidential update identifies board approval among the developments of 2025.Revision approval reported

The January 2026 statement reports the revision alongside other policy changes. The association’s ethics page provides its published code across membership categories.

Effect
The national association updates its professional framework.
Jurisdiction
American Psychoanalytic Association.
Link to this event ↗

03 / Cases & connections

What a consequence
actually meant.

The examples trace the movement from a treatment relationship to an institutional or legal response.

Two further accounts examine reported professional consequences and the attribution of responsibility in the 1960s.

1970s–1990s

Pressure from outside the profession

Feminist criticism challenged psychoanalysis’s theories of women and the way its institutions responded to abuse. Young-Bruehl and Dunbar describe pervasive sexism in analytic training, common boundary violations, and more than a decade of institutional resistance. They credit feminist criticism and the growing influence of women and nonmedical practitioners with changing psychoanalytic theory and technique.

That pressure gives the cases here a wider setting. In the Masserman case, Barbara Noel’s book and Ann Landers’s column prompted the American Psychiatric Association to publicly identify a suspension it had already imposed. Professional sanction and public disclosure were separate battles.

[34] [31]

Read the Masserman case ↗

01 / Treatment → damages → coverageZipkin & FreemanA $17,000 judgment, then a dispute about who would pay.Read the case

The jury’s 1963 award and the 1968 insurance decision are separate events. One imposed liability; the other determined coverage. The case shows how ordinary malpractice principles could reach misconduct woven into a treatment relationship.

[35]

02 / Patient money → institutional powerPollock & the Chicago InstituteFinancial entanglement ends a directorship.Read the case

Schechter describes an institute whose patients and former patients also participated in fundraising and governance. Pollock’s receipt of patient money brought those overlapping roles into an ethics proceeding in 1988.

Her account of the ouster draws on the institution’s later recollection of the crisis. It makes visible how the same personal networks could sustain an institute and complicate its response.

[27]

03 / Local decisions → national review → appealThe 2006 APsA proceedingAn association’s own minutes show its disciplinary machinery at work.Read the case

The sequence in the minutes is concrete: review of two local decisions, an expulsion vote, an appeal by the member, and approval of the required appeals committee. The recorded stage is an expulsion decision under appeal.

[3]

04 / Professional code → state standardCalifornia in 2026An association’s ethics gains governmental force.Read the case

California first moved its research-psychoanalyst registration program to the Board of Psychology. The following year, § 2954.6 directed the board to apply APsA ethics in its enforcement and disciplinary evaluations.

The scope is the state’s research-psychoanalyst registration category. Within that category, a professional association’s code now supplies a standard for governmental oversight.

[8] [9]

05 / 1963 / Reported treatment relationship and marriageDavid Rubinfine and Elaine MayA treatment relationship becomes a marriage.Read the case

Evan Osnos reports that Elaine May married her analyst, David Rubinfine, in 1963. Berman and Mosher date the marriage to June 8 and, drawing on Farber and Green’s Hollywood on the Couch, describe their romance as developing during analysis (2022, p. 34). Their account doesn’t establish an exact termination date.

Interpretation: the chronology places the analyst’s clinical responsibility at the center of the account. A marriage date, professional disapproval and a documented disciplinary decision are different kinds of historical evidence. This case records the reported relationship; any claim about a particular institutional sanction requires its own supporting record.

[25] [6] [10]

06 / 1965 / Recollection, professional standing and blameVictor H. Rosen and Elise SnyderA former patient’s account of a marriage and its professional aftermath.Read the case

Elise Snyder told Osnos that she returned to her former analyst, Victor Rosen, for a consultation about a nightmare. During the visit, she recalled, he declared that he loved her. They married in 1965. Berman and Mosher recount this interview and distinguish an alternative account of the romance’s beginning (2022, pp. 29–30).

Rosen served as American Psychoanalytic Association president in 1965–1966. The association’s officer table lists him in 1965 and Leo Rangell in 1966; its note places the start of terms at the annual meeting. The Cornell collection’s officer-file listing independently identifies Rosen’s presidential files as 1965–1966 (p. 38).

Osnos reports that Rosen left a position at the New York Psychoanalytic Institute and that Heinz Kohut feared damage to psychoanalysis’s standing. Snyder described colleagues treating her as the woman who had seduced Rosen. These are reported institutional consequences and her recollection of blame; the account doesn’t identify a formal disciplinary finding.

Interpretation: Berman and Mosher locate responsibility for maintaining the clinical boundary with the analyst (p. 30). Snyder’s account shows how professional blame could instead attach to the patient. The loss of a position, reputational damage and an enforceable sanction each need to be described on their own evidence.

[25] [6] [5] [30] [10]

07 / License → suspension → public noticeJules H. Masserman and the APAA state consent order, a five-year suspension, and a public statement after patient pressure.Read the case

Jules H. Masserman trained as a psychoanalyst in Chicago and later served as president of the American Psychiatric Association. Former patients accused him of drugging and sexually assaulting them during treatment. By September 1992, four lawsuits had settled out of court, one had been dismissed as untimely, and one remained pending. Those settlements weren’t judicial findings. Masserman denied the allegations.

On October 7, 1987, he surrendered his Illinois medical license and authority to practice psychotherapy under a consent order. In 1991 the American Psychiatric Association and the Illinois Psychiatric Society suspended him for five years following an ethics proceeding. This was disciplinary action by psychiatric associations, not by the American Psychoanalytic Association.

The national suspension didn’t initially receive the publicity of an expulsion. Barbara Noel challenged that silence in her 1992 book. After Ann Landers took up the issue in September, the APA trustees authorized a public statement naming Masserman. The distinction between a sanction and the public’s ability to learn about it’s what makes this case important to the history of accountability.

[24] [21] [31] [18]

04 / From a complaint to a decision

How a rule becomes
an enforceable decision.

BPSI’s 2017 procedures provide one concrete institute model. They set out a complaint process, a hearing, sanctions, and an appeal. [7]

  1. 01Complaint

    A written allegation or qualifying official record establishes the matter for review.

  2. 02Investigation

    Investigators gather evidence; a panel assesses probable cause.

  3. 03Hearing & finding

    The parties can present and question evidence before a decision.

  4. 04Sanction & appeal

    Findings can lead to corrective measures or loss of membership, with appeal rights.

What can prevent a case from reaching a decision?

Honig and Barron’s account of a 2010 institute crisis shows how resignations and the absence of a complainant stalled the formal process. BPSI’s later published procedures retain jurisdiction over pending complaints and allow certain complaints filed within one year after resignation. [16] [7]

Read the 2010 account ↗
Where does insurance fit?

Health insurance governs payment for covered treatment. Malpractice insurance concerns defense and liability coverage. In Zipkin, a damages judgment came first; the later litigation determined the insurer’s obligation to pay. [35]

Private payment leaves licensing duties and applicable professional rules in place. HIPAA coverage depends on the provider’s qualifying electronic transactions; cash payment by itself doesn’t decide it. [11] [2] [32]

Which standards apply to a psychoanalyst today?

The answer follows the practitioner’s license or registration, state, professional memberships, and setting. APsA’s published code applies across its membership categories and prohibits sexual relationships with current or former patients, while also regulating financial and institutional exploitation. [2]

California’s research-psychoanalyst registration offers a direct link between the systems: its statute directs the board to apply APsA ethics in enforcement. [9]

05 / Sources & reading

The record behind
the rules.

Historical scholarship sits alongside association records, court judgments, statutes, and government publications. Each event links to the sources supporting its date and outcome.

The profession taking shape

Nathan G. Hale Jr.

The Rise and Crisis of Psychoanalysis in the United States supplies the institutional setting for membership, training, and the struggle over who could practice.

Read the reference ↓
Institutions under pressure

Schechter · Honig & Barron

Institutional histories bring fundraising, professional loyalties, resignations, and the practical work of enforcing ethics into view.

Schechter ↓ Honig & Barron ↓
How to read the evidence

The kind of event matters. “Rule / framework” marks a standard or system; “judicial ruling” identifies a legal holding; “consequence” records a judgment, removal, or settlement. Proceedings and institutional responses have their own labels.

Dates follow the event described. Enactment, effective dates, trial judgments, and appeals are identified separately. Case titles retain their court citations. The five timeline rows identify the principal authority involved.

The selection follows the United States, 1930–October 2026. It combines psychoanalytic institutional history with laws and decisions governing the professions through which analysts practice. Scope and jurisdiction appear with every event.

References are ordered by author or institutional / case name. References identify the works cited. Updated November 11, 2026.

The full bibliography 35 resources
  1. 01
    Institutional & reference sources

    1986 Minnesota Laws, chapter 372. https://www.revisor.mn.gov/laws/1986/0/372/

  2. 02
    Institutional & reference sources

    American Psychoanalytic Association. (n.d.). APsA code of ethics. https://apsa.org/wp-content/uploads/2024/02/APsA-Code-of-Ethics.pdf

  3. 03
    Institutional & reference sources

    American Psychoanalytic Association. (2006, June 15). Minutes: Meeting of the Executive Council. https://apsa.org/wp-content/uploads/2022/02/Executive-Council-Minutes-6-15-06.pdf

  4. 04
    Institutional & reference sources

    American Psychoanalytic Association. (2012, June). Position statement on sexual orientation, gender identity, and civil rights. https://apsa.org/wp-content/uploads/2022/02/2012-Position-Statement-on-Sexual-Orientation-Gender-Identity-and-Civil-Rights.pdf

  5. 05
    Institutional & reference sources

    American Psychoanalytic Association. (2019). Chronological table of officers and meetings (1965–1966 rows and term-of-office note). https://apsa.org/wp-content/uploads/2022/02/CHRONOLOGICAL-TABLE-OF-OFFICERS-AND-MEETINGS-2019.pdf

  6. 06
    Papers & articles

    Berman, J., & Mosher, P. (2022). A brief history of sexual boundary violations. International Journal of Controversial Discussions, 2(1), 11–47.

  7. 07
    Institutional & reference sources

    Boston Psychoanalytic Society and Institute. (2017, September 7). Ethics committee policies and procedures. https://portal.bpsi.org/wp-content/uploads/2022/10/BPSI-Ethics-Committee-Policies-and-Procedures-9.7.2017.pdf

  8. 08
    Institutional & reference sources

    California Board of Psychology. (2023, Winter). Journal of the California Board of Psychology (Issue 40).

  9. 09
    Institutional & reference sources

    California Business and Professions Code § 2954.6 (2026). https://law.justia.com/codes/california/code-bpc/division-2/chapter-6-6/article-3-5/section-2954-6/

  10. 10
    Books & chapters

    Farber, S., & Green, M. (1993). Hollywood on the couch: A candid look at the overheated love affair between psychiatrists and moviemakers. William Morrow.

  11. 11
    Institutional & reference sources

    Federation of State Medical Boards. (n.d.). Information for consumers. https://www.fsmb.org/guide-to-medical-regulation-in-the-united-states/information-for-consumers/

  12. 12
    Books & chapters

    Hale, N. G., Jr. (1995). The rise and crisis of psychoanalysis in the United States: Freud and the Americans, 1917–1985. Oxford University Press.

  13. 13
    Institutional & reference sources

    Hammer v. Rosen, 7 N.Y.2d 376 (1960). https://www.casemine.com/judgement/us/59149d6eadd7b0493464f5bf

  14. 14
    Institutional & reference sources

    Health Resources and Services Administration. (n.d.). NPDB data analysis tool: Methodology. https://npdb.hrsa.gov/resources/methods.jsp

  15. 15
    Institutional & reference sources

    Health Resources and Services Administration. (n.d.). What you must report to the NPDB. https://www.npdb.hrsa.gov/hcorg/whatYouMustReportToTheDataBank.jsp

  16. 16
    Papers & articles

    Honig, R. G., & Barron, J. W. (2013). Restoring institutional integrity in the wake of sexual boundary violations: A case study. Journal of the American Psychoanalytic Association, 61(5), 897–924.

  17. 17
    Institutional & reference sources

    Jaffee v. Redmond, 518 U.S. 1 (1996). https://supreme.justia.com/cases/federal/us/518/1/

  18. 18
    Papers & articles

    Lazarus, J. A., & Sharfstein, S. S. (1992, October 16). APA acts against ethics violators. Psychiatric News, 27(20), 14.

  19. 19
    Archives & interviews

    Levy, J., & Ludewig, S. (2022, October 20). Behind the scenes: Collecting enigmas. Library of Congress.

    View source

  20. 20
    Papers & articles

    Lewes, K., Young-Bruehl, E., Roughton, R., Magee, M., & Miller, D. C. (2008). Homosexuality and psychoanalysis I: Historical perspectives. Journal of Gay & Lesbian Mental Health, 12(4), 299–323.

  21. 21
    Papers & articles

    McCracken, D. (1992, September 27). Trust betrayed: Sex abuse by therapists prompts ethical debate. Chicago Tribune.

  22. 22
    Institutional & reference sources

    National Association for the Advancement of Psychoanalysis v. California Board of Psychology, 228 F.3d 1043 (9th Cir. 2000). https://law.justia.com/cases/federal/appellate-courts/F3/228/1043/478769/

  23. 23
    Institutional & reference sources

    New York State Education Department. (2012, June 29). Report to the Legislature and the Executive pursuant to Chapters 130 & 132 of the Laws of 2010.

  24. 24
    Books & chapters

    Noel, B., with Watterson, K. (1992). You must be dreaming. Poseidon Press.

  25. 25
    Papers & articles

    Osnos, E. (2011, January 10). Meet Dr. Freud. The New Yorker, 54–63. (Published online January 2, 2011.)

  26. 26
    Institutional & reference sources

    Roy v. Hartogs, 81 Misc. 2d 350, 366 N.Y.S.2d 297 (N.Y. Civ. Ct. 1975). https://www.casemine.com/judgement/us/59149600add7b049345d96d6

  27. 27
    Papers & articles

    Schechter, K. A. (2010). Illusions of a future: Psychoanalysis and the biopolitics of desire (Publication No. 3419694) [Doctoral dissertation, University of Chicago]. ProQuest Dissertations & Theses.

  28. 28
    Institutional & reference sources

    State v. Eichman, 155 Wis. 2d 552, 455 N.W.2d 143 (1990). https://law.justia.com/cases/wisconsin/supreme-court/1990/88-1754-c-9.html

  29. 29
    Institutional & reference sources

    Tarasoff v. Regents of the University of California, 17 Cal. 3d 425 (1976). https://law.justia.com/cases/california/supreme-court/3d/17/425.html

  30. 30
    Archives & interviews

    The Winthrop Group. (2008, March). American Psychoanalytic Association collection: Folder list (p. 38). Oskar Diethelm Library, Weill Cornell Medical College.

    View source

  31. 31
    Papers & articles

    Trustees respond to Landers column on patient-doctor sex. (1992, October 16). Psychiatric News, 27(20), 1, 21.

  32. 32
    Institutional & reference sources

    U.S. Department of Health and Human Services. (n.d.). Summary of the HIPAA Privacy Rule. https://www.hhs.gov/hipaa/for-professionals/privacy/laws-regulations/index.html

  33. 33
    Institutional & reference sources

    U.S. Department of Health and Human Services. (2023, March 28). Manasa Health Center LLC resolution agreement and corrective action plan. https://www.hhs.gov/hipaa/for-professionals/compliance-enforcement/agreements/manasa-ra-cap/index.html

  34. 34
    Books & chapters

    Young-Bruehl, E., & Dunbar, C. (2009). One hundred years of psychoanalysis: A timeline, 1900–2000 [Foldout timeline]. Caversham Productions.

  35. 35
    Institutional & reference sources

    Zipkin v. Freeman, 436 S.W.2d 753 (Mo. 1968). https://law.justia.com/cases/missouri/supreme-court/1968/53160-0.html

Top