Female sexuality and sexual difference
The development of femininity was disputed within psychoanalysis. Freud, Deutsch, Horney, and Jones assigned different roles to anatomy, identification, desire, and social conditions. Horney challenged the male standpoint built into explanations of women’s development. Her early arguments retained a place for bodily differences while questioning the claim that femininity must be understood as a response to lacking male anatomy.
Hale also describes Beatrice Hinkle’s criticism of equating feminine sexuality with passivity or introversion. These disagreements cross the boundaries between Freudian, Jungian, and cultural approaches; women’s contributions changed the theoretical arguments themselves.
Freudian psychoanalysis · Analytical psychology · Cultural / neo-Freudian · Kleinian psychoanalysis
Horney, K. (2000); Hale, N. G., Jr. (1995); Appignanesi, L., & Forrester, J. (1992).
Later readings · 1991–2008
In her 1991 study of representations of the clitoris, Nancy Kulish examines female bodily pleasure and the meanings analysts give it. Kulish and Deanna Holtzman’s Persephone model keeps the mother within the girl’s erotic and competitive relationships as attachment to the father develops. Their 2008 book returns explicitly to Horney’s challenge to a male-centered account of female development. Dianne Elise’s 2002 account gives mother–daughter desire its own place in the formation of female sexual subjectivity.
Later perspectives on female sexual development
Kulish, 1991; Kulish & Holtzman, 2008; Elise, 2002.
Narcissism and creative life · 1912–1913
In her Vienna journal Lou Andreas-Salomé treated narcissism as more than an infantile stage to be left behind or a pathological withdrawal. Her entries in November 1912 and August 1913 described a continuing interplay between self-regard, attachment, desire, and creative life. Her distinct emphasis on the enduring, generative possibilities of narcissism anticipated the position she developed more publicly in the 1921 essay The Dual Orientation of Narcissism.
This was an independent contribution from a participant in Freud’s circle, not a later clinician silently repeating Freud. The diary also shows how work with Viktor Tausk and conversations with Freud helped her think through the issues; intellectual exchange didn’t eliminate their differences.
Freudian psychoanalysis
Andreas-Salomé, L. (1987).
Same-sex desire, theory, and prejudice · 1890s–1944
In the 1890s, Freud and Wilhelm Fliess discussed bisexuality and sexual development. Fliess proposed that male and female characteristics coexisted within each person. Freud took up psychic bisexuality in his theory of repression. In 1899 he considered homosexuality, masturbation, and early sexual wishes together. Their 1904 disagreement concerned Hermann Swoboda, Otto Weininger, and the circulation and authorship of the theory.
Lou Andreas-Salomé’s November 1912 journal documents an early dispute over how to interpret homosexuality. She rejected Alfred Adler’s move from one patient’s case to a general claim that same-sex desire was a neurotic fiction, while distinguishing an enduring orientation from a symptom constructed within a particular conflict. Her account is still shaped by gendered and developmental assumptions of its period. In February 1913 she also noted Freud discussing psychic bisexuality as a possible resource in development; the concept must not simply be equated with modern bisexual orientation.
Analysts offered changing explanations of women’s same-sex desire. Young-Bruehl traces a sequence from Freud’s emphasis on masculine identification in 1920, through Jones and Klein’s accounts of a defensive retreat from heterosexuality, to Deutsch’s emphasis on attachment to the early mother in 1944. The accounts became more pathologizing, yet the idea of one female-homosexual type persisted. Young-Bruehl’s objection is specific: the same conflicts could occur in women who loved men, and exceptions didn’t dislodge the category.
Sándor Radó’s 1940 criticism of universal bisexuality marked a sharper turn. His account treated heterosexuality as the normal developmental course and homosexuality as a pathological departure from it. Kenneth Lewes places that argument within a wider hardening of psychoanalytic opinion during the 1930s.
There were alternatives within the early movement. In The Book of the It (1923), Georg Groddeck turned the question toward the observer: why was passion between people of the same sex so difficult to consider without prejudice?
Bruno Veneziani’s successive analyses with Sadger, Freud, Reitler, Tausk and Abraham brought the question of homosexual life into different clinical settings. Freud’s 1920 letter to Weiss identified homosexuality separately from the addictions and conflicts he believed made further analysis unpromising. Carl Liebmann’s treatment later supplied the support-belt example in Fetishism (1927). These encounters connect sexual theory with the histories of named patients.
Freudian psychoanalysis · Kleinian psychoanalysis
Young-Bruehl, E. (2000); Lewes, K., Young-Bruehl, E., Roughton, R., Magee, M., & Miller, D. C. (2008); Andreas-Salomé, L. (1987); Freud, S. (1985); Borch-Jacobsen, 2021; May, 2018; Freud & Abraham, 2002; Weiss, E. (1991); Freud, 1927; Freud & Pfister, 1963.
Trauma, experience, and the analyst’s participation
In April 1897 Freud described a woman’s account of childhood sexual abuse by her father. In September he reconsidered his theory that paternal seduction explained every case of hysteria. In December he reported that Emma Eckstein had treated a young female patient and described what she’d learned about the patient’s experiences. The letters record Freud’s changing ideas about sexual trauma, memory, and fantasy.
Lou Andreas-Salomé’s 1912–1913 journal records her observations of shared analytic work with Viktor Tausk in Vienna and considers the analyst’s emotional participation in transference. These are earlier conversations within Freud’s circle, not the same as Ferenczi’s later clinical experiments (Andreas-Salomé, 1987).
In 1928, Marie Bonaparte published a study drawing on her identification with her dead mother. She connected obsessive images of the mother’s corpse and persistent fear of death with early maternal loss. Maternal loss also became a central subject of her study of Edgar Allan Poe, published in French in 1933.
War neuroses also shaped the reconsideration of trauma in the 1920s. Young-Bruehl and Dunbar describe the stimulus supplied by Ernst Simmel’s use of hypnosis and catharsis and by Ferenczi’s and Abraham’s wartime clinical work. Their account follows the growing attention to how traumatic experience and unconscious fantasy interact, including the later reactivation of an earlier experience.
Ferenczi’s later work examined how adult coercion and the denial of a child’s experience could become traumatic. His experiments with technique made the analyst’s responsiveness, authority, and failures part of the clinical investigation. Mutual analysis was a particular late experiment, rather than a shared Budapest method.
In The Discovery of the Self (1933), Elizabeth Severn described nightmares as “records of personal catastrophes.” She understood dream life as an attempt to transform disturbing experiences and make them bearable. She connected nightmares with earlier shocks and psychic disintegration.
In “Some Palaeobiological and Biopsychical Reflections” (1938), Bonaparte described anxiety about bodily penetration and destruction through the perforation complex. She argued that anxiety originates in objective danger. Discussing Anna Freud’s classification of anxiety, she proposed the organism’s response to danger as a common foundation for its different forms.
Kovács located the analyst’s countertransference within the work of training and supervision. Thompson carried Ferenczi’s influence into American interpersonal work. The question of what the analyst contributes to the encounter therefore links traditions that developed different explanations of mental life.
In her 2026 interview, Agnes Sobolewska Alsberg connects Ferenczi’s language of psychic fragmentation with images of a dismembered Hungary circulating after the Treaty of Trianon. Sobolewska places Ferenczi’s and Severn’s emphasis on mutuality within the growth of nationalism, antisemitism, and fascism in interwar Central Europe. She presents their rejection of authoritarian relationships in analysis as a political position as well as a clinical one.
The Budapest tradition · Will & relationship therapy · Interpersonal psychoanalysis · Freudian psychoanalysis
Rudnytsky, P. L. (2022); Kovács, V. (1936); Naszkowska, K. (Ed.). (2024); Hale, N. G., Jr. (1995); Andreas-Salomé, L. (1987); Sobolewska Alsberg, A. (2026a); Sobolewska Alsberg, A. (2026b); Sobolewska Alsberg, A. (2026, November 1); Freud, S. (1985); Young-Bruehl & Dunbar, 2009.
Access to treatment, education, and social reform
Hale describes the Berlin Polyclinic as an effort to realize Freud’s proposal that psychotherapy should reach people unable to pay private fees. Its educational role developed alongside this clinical purpose. Philanthropic support helped establish institutions outside the existing university and medical systems.
The history edited by Naszkowska places Hilferding’s Adlerian work within educational counselling and social welfare. Its Budapest chapter describes Kovács’s low-fee work and the Polyclinic’s training community. Access, education, and social conditions were practical concerns across several analytic traditions.
The Berlin Polyclinic opened in 1920 and Vienna’s Ambulatorium in 1922. Young-Bruehl and Dunbar connect these free clinics with analysts’ socialist and Social Democratic commitments and Freud’s support for treatment across social classes. Access to analysis belonged to an interwar argument about public provision as well as a program of private philanthropy.
Individual psychology · The Budapest tradition · Freudian psychoanalysis · Cultural / neo-Freudian
Hale, N. G., Jr. (1995); Naszkowska, K. (Ed.). (2024); Young-Bruehl & Dunbar, 2009.
Marxism, analytic discussion, and exile
Otto Fenichel’s Berlin Children’s Seminar brought analysts together around political and clinical questions. When members went into exile during the 1930s, his Rundbriefe kept their discussions moving between cities. The letters helped sustain an intellectual community after its shared meeting place was lost.
Before the Second World War, Frankfurt was another setting for exchanges between psychoanalysis and Marxism. Erich Fromm worked as an analyst, while Max Horkheimer and Theodor Adorno approached the questions as philosophers. Young-Bruehl and Dunbar place these exchanges alongside debates about sexual repression, authority, and social conditions.
Freudian psychoanalysis · Character analysis · Cultural / neo-Freudian
Young-Bruehl & Dunbar, 2009.
Psychosis and the reach of analytic treatment
Work with severely disturbed patients raised questions about whom psychoanalytic understanding could reach and what treatment should try to accomplish. Sullivan’s interpersonal psychiatry and Fromm-Reichmann’s intensive clinical work developed in psychiatric settings, while Fairbairn’s papers reconsidered schizoid processes and the organization of internal relationships.
These were distinct responses to problems that conventional symptom categories and a single model of treatment didn’t resolve. The interpersonal situation, defensive withdrawal, and attachment to painful internal objects supplied different routes into clinical understanding.
Interpersonal psychoanalysis · Other object-relations approaches · Kleinian psychoanalysis
Hale, N. G., Jr. (1995); Fairbairn, W. R. D. (1994).
Child observation, separation, and care
Child analysis brought the child’s actual dependence into debate with theories reconstructed from play and transference. Anna Freud and Burlingham studied children’s circumstances and wartime separation. Klein interpreted early anxieties and internal relationships through analytic work with children. Balint and Winnicott investigated early relatedness and developmental processes in different terms.
These differences concern both explanation and evidence: what an observer can see, what an analyst can infer, and how actual caregiving enters the account of psychic life. They connect child analysis, ego psychology, and object-relations theories without making them interchangeable.
The disagreement took institutional form as well. Klein and Anna Freud exchanged opposing positions in the 1927 child-analysis symposium; after Anna Freud reached London in 1938, the dispute continued within the British Society. Young-Bruehl and Dunbar trace the tension between interpretation of internal conflict and attention to children’s dependence on their surroundings.
Anna Freudian child analysis · Kleinian psychoanalysis · The Budapest tradition · Other object-relations approaches
King, P., & Steiner, R. (Eds.). (1991); Grosskurth, P. (1987); Balint, M. (1949); Winnicott, D. W. (1945); Naszkowska, K. (Ed.). (2024); Young-Bruehl & Dunbar, 2009.
French beginnings: transmission, lay analysis, and child work
Naszkowska’s collection follows Sokolnicka’s arrival in Paris in 1921, her work in literary circles, her training of analysts, and the obstacles she encountered as a non-medical practitioner. She became a founding member of the Paris Psychoanalytical Society in 1926. The early French story includes the transmission of psychoanalysis through clinical, literary, and institutional networks.
Marie Bonaparte’s study of Edgar Allan Poe appeared in French in 1933 with an introduction by Freud. In “A Defense of Biography” (1939), she defended preserving intimate personal records as sources for biography.
Sophie Morgenstern developed child work using drawing, play, and storytelling. Her attention to the family situation and the child’s trust in the analyst adds another path to the history of child analysis. These developments precede the mature Lacanian movement and deserve a place alongside its early beginnings.
Freudian psychoanalysis · Anna Freudian child analysis · Kleinian psychoanalysis
Naszkowska, K. (Ed.). (2024); Sobolewska Alsberg, A. (2026a); Sobolewska Alsberg, A. (2025).
Concrete psychology and child development · 1928–1938
In his 1928 Critique of the Foundations of Psychology, Georges Politzer argued that psychology should begin with a person’s lived experience—the “drama” of a life—rather than as a collection of hidden mechanisms. He credited Freud’s interpretation of dreams with breaking from abstract psychology while objecting that Freud’s concept of the unconscious restored some abstractions. Politzer was proposing a different foundation for psychology.
Henri Wallon approached Freud differently. He drew on Freud’s displacement and condensation to describe the emergence of symbolic meaning. His work on mental development connected bodily experience and social relations without adopting psychoanalysis. The 1938 volume La vie mentale, directed by Wallon, also published Lacan’s essay La famille, with an early account of the mirror stage.
Freudian psychoanalysis
Maher, M. (2026); Politzer, G. (1994); Wallon, H. (1930); Wallon, H. (Ed.). (1938).
Patients’ lives and their published case histories · 1889–1945
Freud’s early case histories turned women’s symptoms and speech into accounts of hysteria and unconscious conflict. The people later identified as Emmy von N., Elisabeth von R., Katharina and Dora were Fanny Moser, Ilona Weiss, Aurelia Kronich and Ida Bauer. Their personal histories continued beyond the moments Freud selected for publication.
Ilona Weiss’s daughter recorded her mother rejecting the interpretation that she loved her brother-in-law. Ida Bauer ended her analysis and later criticized Freud’s account. Fanny Moser’s family history and subsequent correspondence preserve changes in the clinical story. Anna von Lieben’s Viennese salon and treatment arrangements situate the early method in a wider social world.
Adele Jeiteles recalled stopping her consultations because she objected to questions about sexuality. Rosa Mayreder, whose husband Karl entered treatment in 1915, recorded her disagreement with interpretations of their marriage. These records give patients and relatives distinct voices within the history of psychoanalytic theory.
Cathartic beginnings · Freudian psychoanalysis · Cultural / neo-Freudian
Explore the people and connections ↗
Borch-Jacobsen, 2021; Appignanesi, L., & Forrester, J. (1992); May, 2018; Freud & Abraham, 2002.