History of Psychoanalysis

Papers on Psycho-Analysis · Part II: Papers on dreams

Dream Manipulation of Numbers

Ernest JonesChapter XI of XLPrinted pages 242–247About 12 min

An exploration of numbers in dreams and unconscious associations shaping apparently arbitrary choices.

Type size
Chapter XI

p. 242 notes THERE is perhaps no other experience in psycho-analysis that so taxes one’s credulity as the occasions where numbers are found to be manipulated for intelligent reasons by the unconscious. Of the existence of the process itself, which has been illustrated by Freud, Adler, Stekel, Jung,and Tausk, no one can be in any doubt who has personally investigated the matter, but some of the more complicated examples related in the literature, particularly some of those quoted by Stekel, seem almost physically impossible to believe. Jung has very pointedly said — in this connection:? ‘Die Grenzen, wo das rein Spielerische anfangt, sind schwer zu ziehen—notwendigerweise, denn das unbewusste Produkt ist Schépfung spielender Phantasie, jener psychischen Instanz, aus der auch das Spiel entsteht. Es widerstrebt dem exakten Geiste dieser nach allen Seiten ins Haltlose sich verlierenden Spielerei nachzuhangen.’ (‘It is hard to define the limits where pure play begins—necessarily

so, for the unconscious product is the creation of the playing phantasy, of that psychical factor from which play itself is born. The exact mind finds it repugnant to follow this playtfulness; which on all sides gets lost in indefiniteness.’)

To the unflinching determinist, however, nothing can be ultimately indefinite, and law and order will some day be found to prevail even in the phenomena of mental play. As a matter of fact, accumulation of experience makes one more and more convinced of the remarkable extent to which this curious manipulation of numbers goes on in the unconscious, so that one is led to conceive of our instinctive repugnance to the idea, p. 243 notes our strong disinclination to accept the interpretations that analysis forces on us, as being merely one more form of our general resistance against the unconscious and all its ways. The intensity and universality of this particular repugnance are striking, being much greater than in the case of most interpretations, and one cannot avoid the inference that numbers must be treated by the unconscious mind in a different way from other concepts and perhaps even words. In a _ very thoughtful paper Ferenczi? has pointed out the ways in which obscene words are differently treated from other words, and he adduces plausible reasons to shew that the peculiar significance attaching to them is due to their having retained certain infantile characteristics, notably a capacity for visual and motor imagery that other words have to a great extent lost. It is very possible that a similar infantile fixation has taken place in the case of numbers, and one readily perceives at least three sources for the special significance with which they are invested in the unconscious: (1) The great importance attaching to them in the first stages of the child’s education. The child is taught to count much earlier and more invariably than it is taught to read. (2) The readiness with which the almost magical properties of numbers lend themselves to child-play. Freud’s remark that ‘children treat words as though they were objects’ is even more evidently true of numbers than of words. (3) The close association between numbers and one of the greatest sources of pledsure to children—namely, the fingers. It is significant that nearly every country of both ancient and modern times has based its counting on the decimal system— 1.e.,on the number of fingers. It is thus plain that the whole subject is worth investigating psychologically, for both practical and theoretical reasons, so that the publication of any casuistic material bearing on it is particularly desirable.

In going over the notes of a case, an account of which I have already published elsewhere,? I came across the following example, which seems definite enough to warrant its being related. The notes were made some years ago, at a time when I was much more incredulous on the matter than subsequent experience has made me; they were therefore collected with p. 244 notes a bias against them, quite empirically, and I can guarantee that the interpretations given were all immediate associations offered by the patient.

The patient, a man of twenty-four, was suffering from a severe obsessional neurosis and was very superstitious; it should further be said that he had an unusually pronounced mother-complex. He regarded some numbers—e.g., 3, 9, etc. —as being particularly lucky, and others—e.g., 4, 36, etc.— as being equally unlucky; the former usually referred to himself and the latter to his mother. Thus 3 had the usual sexual-symbolic meaning for him, and 9, 3 times 3, had this in a higher degree; 9 represented the maximum of sexual potency, and he told me that this was the highest number of times he had ever accomplished the sexual act in a single night. 4, on the other hand, was his mother’s ‘sacred number,’ which he attributed to the circumstance that she was the fourth member of her family. 36 was especially connected with his mother, because she was that age when she died (7 years previously).

One night he dreamed that he was vainly trying to find his old home in a certain street where he had lived until about the age of seven. After considerable difficulty he managed, however, to recognise the door number and joyfully exclaimed ‘ Yes, that’s it, number 72.. Hethen woke up. Now, in reality the number of the house in question was 243, as heat once recollected when awake, and as I took the trouble to verify by asking a relative of his. Two alterations, therefore, had been made by the dream: (a) The last two numerals, 4 and 3, had been added together, the whole then making 27, and (db) the two components of this had been reversed into 72. These alterations clearly could have been made in one of two ways, according to which was made first:in one way the adding would occur first and the reversing second, the order of the stages being 243, 27, 72; 1n the other way the reversing would occur

first and the adding second, the order then being 243, 432, 72. It might be expected that one could find out the order by p. 245 observing whether the first or the second middle number (27 or 432) was the more closely associated with the train of thought connecting the whole. As we shall see, however, these two numbers seemed equally prominent, if we are to judge from the ‘free associations,’ and J imagine that both of these alternative procedures had been carried out in the patient’s unconscious, of course at different moments; this again is in accord with what we know of the play-attitude towards numbers, every possible game being experimented with.

The patient’s free associations will not be given in the precise order in which they occurred, but will be arranged in groups so as to make them easier to follow.

We begin with 72, the erroneous number in the dream. To this he remarked that 72 equals 36 X2. 72 was the age at which his grandmother, of whom he had been specially fond, had died. 36 was the age at which his mother had died. 2 was the only numeral common to the correct and the false numbers of the house, 243 and 72. There were 2 people for whom his imagination longed, both represented by the age at which they had died. The whole psycho-analysis shewed that the function of the distortion of the number, as also that of the dream throughout, was the artificial bringing of himself and his mother together in his imagination. This was accomplished in the case of the number by means of various manipulations of the numerals 3 and 9g, which stood for himself, and 4, which stood for his mother. We may consider separately the two acts of bringing together 3 and 4, and g and 4, respectively.

The simplest way of bringing together 3 and 4, the terminal numerals of 243, was by merely adding them up, giving 27 or the reverse of 72. The same result was reached by adding together the first numerals of the house number 243, which gave him 63, the reverse of the fatal 36—1.e., one half of 72. Both 72 and 63 are related to 7, which appears directly in the former and of which the latter is a multiple (with the magic nine, 7X9). The patient was 7 years old when he left the house in question, and 7 years had elapsed since his mother’s death.

The unaltered numbers themselves, 243 and 36, which had to be brought together, standing as they did for home and mother, are both closely connected with 3 and 4. 243 not only contains both these numerals in what might be called its manifest content, but it is made up of 3 X3 X3 X3 X3—7.-é., it represented an enormously high degree of potency. On the p. 246 second alternative mentioned previously—1z.e., if the reversal took place before the adding—we get 432 as a middle number, which is also made up of (3 X3x3) X(4 x4), or a strong bringing together of 3 and 4. On the other hand, 36 is made up of 3X3 x4, and if the second numeral alone is decomposed the number can be written 3 (3+3). The reverse of the final 72—1.e., 27—can itself be decomposed into 3 X33, while the 72 is divisible by both 3 and 4. We thus see that the figures 3 and 4 are remarkably closely connected with all the numbers concerned in the manipulative procedure.

The same is evidently true of the other personal number, 9, which need not be pointed out in detail. It is enough to remark that not only are all the numbers concerned, 243, 432,

63, 36, 27, 72, without exception divisible by 9, but also in every one of these six numbers the individual numerals composing them when added together give 9 as the result. It must be admitted that the natural properties of the numbers in question were singularly well adapted for the patient’s purpose, and thus enabled him to reinforce and reiterate the idea of the coming together of himself and his mother, but it must also be admitted that he realised the unusual opportunity and fully availed himself of it. He gave full vent to his passionate desire to bring together the numbers 3 and 4, and 9 and 4, and found out every way in which this was possible.

As if all this were not refinement enough, the patient pointed out still other possibilities in the numbers. In America the number 23 is colloquially associated with the ideas both of death and of sudden departure, a superstition the origin of which is irrelevant to our present theme, but one which was shared by the patient as well as most other superstitions. Now, if 4, his mother’s sacred number, is removed from any one of the numbers in question (thus representing the mother’s death), then in every case the fatal number 23 is left. With 243 the 4 has simply to be struck out, with 63 and 27 it has only to be subtracted from the highest numeral; after striking it out from 432, or subtracting it from the highest numeral of 36 and 72, the result has only to be reversed to give 23.

In conclusion, one may comment on the resemblance, or rather the identity, of the mechanisms here in play and those which Freud has taught us are characteristic of dream formation ingeneral. Inthe change from the 243 in the latent content of

the dream to the 72 of the manifest content we see the condensa- p. 247 notes tion of the two terminal numerals into one, the displacement of the psychical accent from the significant 3 and 4, which become replaced, on to the relatively indifferent 2, which remains unaltered, and the highly characteristic reversal of the different parts of the whole. In the ‘dream work,’ as Freud? has pointed out, there is no reckoning of any sort, either correct or false; the manipulation goes on entirely in the latent unconscious thoughts, and is merely taken over by the dreammaking factors in the same way as sentences and other psychical material. Numbers are thus handled by means of the same mechanisms as words, ideas, and scenes, and one might well put the play on numbers by the side of that play on words that is so important in the formation of superficial associations in general; both serve for the disguising and covering of significant but forbidden thoughts, and there is a good reason why the critics of psycho-analysis reject both as far-fetched, arbitrary, or of no consequence.

Notes from the 1920 edition

Original notes are grouped by printed page. The text was extracted from the historical scan; some characters and note markers may contain recognition errors.

Printed page 242 ↩

  1. 1 Published, under the title ‘ Unbewusste Zahlenbehandlungen,’ in the Zentralblatt fur Psychoanalyse, February, 1912, Jahrg. ii., S. 241.
  2. 2 Jung, ‘Ein Beitrag zur Kenntnis des Zahlentraumes,’ Zentralblatt fir Psychoanalyse, Jahrg. i., S. 570.

Printed page 243 ↩

  1. 1 Ferenczi, ‘Contributions to Psycho-Analysis.” English translation by Ernest Jones, 1916, chap. iv.
  2. 2 Ernest Jones, ‘ Einige Falle von Zwangsneurose,’ Jahrbuch dev Psychoanalyse, Bd. iii., Zweiter Fall.

Printed page 244 ↩

  1. 1 At a recent concert I noticed that Mozart’s 39th Symphony was stated on the programme to be his 453rd! This error was presumably made by a process similar to that under consideration, the only difference being that here it is not a question of putting together two numerals to make a larger one, but of decomposing a larger one into its components (9 into 4 and 5).
  2. In psychological language the example in the text is one of ‘ condensation’; this is one of ‘ decomposition.’ In both cases there is a ‘ reversal.’

Printed page 247 ↩

  1. 1 Freud, ‘Die Traumdeutung,’ 4° Aufl., S. 299.

End of Chapter XI

Return to the complete contents

← Previous: A Forgotten Dream. Note on the Œdipus Saving Phantasy Chapter XII · The Relationship Between Dreams and Psychoneurotic Symptoms · In preparation

About this reading edition

This page is an OCR-assisted transcription of Jones’s 1920 London reprint of the revised and enlarged edition. Paragraphs, section headings, original page locations, and page-grouped notes are presented for reading. The text has not yet received a complete line-by-line proofread against the scan, so occasional recognition errors may remain. Jones’s arguments are historical material, not current clinical guidance.

Jones, E. (1920). Dream Manipulation of Numbers. In Papers on psycho-analysis (Rev. & enl. ed., reprint, pp. 242–247). Baillière, Tindall and Cox.