History of Psychoanalysis

Papers on Psycho-Analysis · Part II: Papers on dreams

Some Instances of the Influence of Dreams on Waking Life

Ernest JonesChapter IX of XLPrinted pages 223–230About 16 min

Examples of dreams shaping subsequent actions, beliefs, and symptoms in waking life.

Type size
Chapter IX

p. 223 notes THE days are long past, at least in civilised countries, when the presages furnished by dreams served as incitements to a given course of action, when the gravest projects, the embarking on momentous campaigns, the making or unmaking of rulers, could be decided upon in consequence of a significant dream. Since the decrease—or, more cautiously put, the transformation—of superstition that the last two or three centuries have brought about, conscious reliance on such presages has become a mark of ignorance, and at the present day is not often met with except in the lower classes. It is probable, however, that in more subtle ways many of our waking processes are affected by preceding dreams to a greater extent than is generally recognised. This particularly applies to the occurrence of certain moods, of foreboding, anxiety, galety, and so on, which begin at the moment of waking and frequently last throughout the day; it is often possible to trace these to corresponding affects that dominated the dreams of the preceding night.

In the field of psychopathology similar occurrences may be observed. Féré was, I think, the first to call attention to the fact that the inception of hysterical symptoms can sometimes be traced to a given dream,” and I have noted many instances of this. The subject has been touched on, though not properly elucidated, by several writers,’ the latest being Waterman.’ p. 224 notes It is quite certain that in these cases the dream has played only a secondary part, by constructing a given mental composition from elements that had at one time been fully conscious;? the most that the dream can do, therefore, is to determine the precise form taken by the symptom in question. I have shewn that this also holds true for a certain class of myths and beliefs?

The following three instances are ee of a course of behaviour being grossly determined by a preceding dream. In the first the incentive was throughout consciously recognised, in the second it was half-consciously recognised, and in the third not at all. Yet in all there was reason to believe that behind the surface motives lay deeper ones that were now unconscious in the fullest sense of the word.

The first was related to me by a Canadian engineer. At the age of twenty he had interrupted his studies by accepting a Government appointment which involved the surveying of a distant and previously unexplored tract of country. He was away for two or three years, and became so enamoured of the free life in the woods, with only the Red Indians for company, that he was exceedingly loath to go back to town life. One night he had a most unpleasant anxiety dream to the effect that all his family were dead, and throughout the next day he was very disturbed at the thought. The same dream recurred in three successive nights, and, although he was in general the very reverse of superstitious, the impression thus made on his mind was so vivid that, in order to reassure himself of his family’s safety, he at once went to the nearest post, handed in his resignation, and started for home. Here he found them all well, and they prevailed on him to stay at home and take up his studies again.

The form of the dream, grief at the death of beloved parents, was so very characteristic that one could not avoid grouping it in the class of Freud’s typical dreams—t.e., those the interpretation of which is constant in different persons.’ The natural inference was that the infantile roots of the dream related to repressed and long-forgotten child fancies of antipathy towards the parents, and that these had been brought to life by some p. 225 recent mental experience. I had no opportunity of confirming the first of these conjectures, though the general probability of it is to me from other experience practically conclusive, but as regards the second one the following contributions have some bearing. For some time before the dreams the subject had been troubled by conscience pricks that by his indulging his personal wishes he was disappointing the hopes of a successful career his family had built on him, and the thought several times occurred to him that were it not for them he could follow his own fancy. For two weeks before the dreams his accustomed letters from home had not arrived, and the horrid idea kept crossing his mind that his previous thought, or half wish, might have come true. The distressing dreams, therefore, in which it appeared actually to be true, profoundly disturbed him, and nothing could relieve his anxiety except seeing his family safe at home. One knows how often an unreasonable or exaggerated anxiety and solicitude cover repressed wishes of a hostile nature, as in the case of the unhappy wife who is constantly trembling lest something terrible should befall her unsympathetic husband

The second instance concerned a patient, an unmarried American lady of twenty-six. She was the eldest daughter, and had always been passionately devoted to her mother, regularly taking her side in parental quarrels. Since the age of fourteen she had been obsessed by the fear that her mother, who for many years had suffered from chronic heart disease, might die. She had never left home until, at the age of twenty, she went to an educational centre some two hundred miles away. Here she reproached herself for having left her mother, whom she had always tended. One evening, shortly after receiving a rather bad report of her mother’s health, there was a college debate, and the side she defended had to wear as a sign of their partisanship a small red cloth shield. That night she dreamed that she saw her mother’s bedroom very distinctly. It resembled the actual room in every detail, except that on the wall opposite to the bed was pinned a red shield, and that her mother was lying dead. She woke in horror, and on the next day she travelled home by the first train. Here she found her mother ill in bed, but apparently in no greater danger than usual. Her first act, and surely an extraordinary one, was to pin on to the wall opposite the bed the little red shield. She rationalised this action as being intended to give her mother the opportunity 15 p. 226 notes of looking at an interesting memento. She slept with her mother, and on the second morning after woke to find her dead beside her. The shock of this she had never got over; she tortured herself with remorse that in some mysterious way she was responsible for her mother’s death, she felt herself always haunted by her spirit, and was totally unable to undertake any occupation whatever, even five years after. She suffered from a phobia of red,* and had never been able to revisit her home.

Those unaccustomed to exploring the deeper recesses of the mind will have no difficulty in framing a satisfying explanation of these facts—perhaps somewhat as follows: The dream was merely an expression of a natural fear, which again would beset anyone whose dearest relative suffered from a mortal malady. The later symptoms and reactions are quite comprehensible in a person who had sustained such a peculiarly severe shock. Unfortunately for the truth of this simple explanation, the psycho-analysis I was able to carry out revealed a more complex state of affairs, only a fragment of whichcan here be described. At a very early age the patient had been greatly in love with her father, and had indulged in phantasies in which she saw herself supplanting her mother in various circumstances. About this time a disliked aunt, who lived with them, died, and the idea occurred to the patient that if a similar calamity were to happen to her invalid mother the loss would have its compensations in other directions. The wish here implied was strongly repressed, but lived on in the unconscious, where its activity was manifest only in the reaction formation of the patient’s excessive devotion to her mother and steadily increasing indifference, or rather antipathy, towards her father; a pronounced homosexual tendency aided this process. The college debate, which, significantly enough, was on the topic of divorce and re-marriage, together with the bad report from home, had aroused the unconscious death complex, which came to fairly open expression in her dream. The dream differed from reality in two respects, in the presence of the red shield in the room and in the death of her mother. The patient’s action in bringing about a more complete correspondence between the dream and reality by pinning up the shield in her mother’s room was a symbolic expression of her repressed wish p. 227 notes that the correspondence might be completed in the other respect also.

The third instance was one that I observed some years ago. An old man had been arrested on account of an indecent offence, and had been sent to the asylum. There was no clear evidence of any definite psychosis, the only abnormality found being some slight senile deterioration. He was allowed to go about the grounds on parole, and one day he escaped, went home, and killed his wife and himself. There was a serious outcry in the local newspapers about the supposed remissness of the asylum authorities, and the assistant medical officer in charge of the patient was very perturbed, particularly, perhaps, as he was at the time anticipating an important promotion. One newspaper stated that only recently the relatives had visited the asylum and had warned the doctor that they were afraid of the patient, as he had threatened to kill his wife. The superintendent questioned the different medical officers, who were all sure they had seen no relative and had known nothing of any such threat; the story was subsequently shewn to be a fabrication invented by some one who had a grudge against the asylum authorities. However, two days before the coroner’s inquest, the doctor in question, whom we may call X, came to the superintendent saying that he had a dim recollection of such a visit as that described. As Dr. X had previously been quite sure of the contrary, and was in general of an over-scrupulous and conscientious disposition, the superintendent dismissed it as a fancy born of his perturbation. Still, not only did the memory persist, but its outlines gradually got more clear and defined, so that by the day of the inquest Dr. X was convinced of its reality. It ran in detail as follows: ‘Two ladies visited him in his office at a busy time. A medical colleague was seated at a desk near by. Dr. X was struck by an undue familiarity on the part of the more prominent one, who leaned with her arms across his desk; still it was the other one, who stood at the side, that did most of the talking. They seemed to be relatives, probably daughters, of the patient. His attention was caught by the foreign way in which they pronounced the patient’s name, Merk, and he tried in vain to repeat it after them correctly; in fact, he broke off the conversa- p. 228 tion for this purpose, and it was much the most vivid point in the whole memory. On hearing the ladies’ complaint, he said that he would carefully look into the matter and have the patient taken off parole. When they left, however, he was so busy that he quite forgot the whole matter until two days ago, two days after reading the passage in the newspaper.’ In view of these facts, about which he no longer doubted, Dr. X considered himself responsible for the two deaths, reproached himself bitterly, and was very anxious as to the result of the inquest. He made up his mind to admit his grave remissness, and to offer as the only excuse the fact that he had been at the time much overworked. The superintendent asked him if he could recognise the ladies who had called on him; one he could not, but from the four daughters that were present at the inquest he picked out one as the lady who leaned across his desk. Fortunately, no questions were put to him on the matter, and shortly after it was proved that the story of the visit was a newspaper fabrication.

Dr. X’s recollection must therefore have been a pseudoreminiscence, and indeed the medical colleague in whose presence the visit was supposed to have taken place was positive that nothing of the kind had occurred. The whole story bears the closest resemblance to an account of a dream, notably the remarkable emphasis (psychical intensity) laid on one unimportant passage (the pronunciation of the patient’s name), and the incongruous behaviour of both the visitor and the doctor; in actual life the last thing he would do would be to break off a conversation of vital import in order to discuss a trivial matter. This view was confirmed by the fact that the memory first dawned on him in the early morning immediately after waking; no doubt his half-asleep state contributed to give it a greater air of reality.

One cannot regard this conclusion, however, as being in any way a full explanation of the episode; on the contrary, it is at this point that the real problems begin. Experience shews that when an autochthonous idea acquires an unusual intensity in a person’s mind it must be connected with mental processes of unusual significance to him; these may be either conscious or unconscious, and in the former case they are always connected with still more significant unconscious processes. I had no opportunity of tracing out the underlying processes p. 229 of the experience just related, but I preserved the following notes. After telling me, several times over, of the curious passage in which he had tried to learn from the visitor how ta pronounce the German name, Dr. X went on to say that it reminded him of several fruitless attempts he had made to learn German. Like many alienists, he had realised the difficulty of proceeding with his studies in psychiatry so long as he could not read the German writings on the subject, but, owing to pressure of routine work, lack of opportunity, and possibly of determination, he had not succeeded in achieving this ambition. He had felt much chagrin and self-reproach in consequence, more so of late since the appointment he was then hoping to get was one that offered unusual opportunities for original investigation. It was thus evident that the self-reproach he had suffered during the episode related above was no new experience to him. From analogy with other cases of exaggerated self-reproach, felt even on imaginary occasions—as here—one is safe in inferring that this trait was an important one in his character, and this was borne out by his general conscientious scrupulousness. Without doubt this must have arisen in deep and highly significant experiences in the past, almost certainly in early childhood, forming what are called guilt-complexes, but I regret that I am not in a position to add anything more in this regard.

Returning briefly to the general question, I would call attention to the following two considerations: Probably more of our daily conduct, moods, and beliefs than we think can be traced to preceding dreams. This is true of the normal, and perhaps to an even greater extent of the abnormal; one thinks at once of such matters as medium experiences, spiritism, telepathy, and the like. A much more important consideration, however, is the fact that the dream is never the ultimate origin of such beliefs, symptoms, etc. In the three instances. just narrated, and in all others I have observed, it was evident that the dream itself was merely a continuation of previous waking mental experiences, a conclusion which is, I think, accepted by those who have studied the subject as being generally true of all dreams. The most that the dream can do is sometimes to give the mental process in question its particular form. To trace a given process to a preceding dream is thus only a step, and by no means an important one, towards the elucidation of it. It p. 230 notes constitutes merely an intermediate stage in the proper analysis,* the next, and far more important one, being the elucidation of the dream itself. It was this empiric experience, that psycho-analysis of various mental processes frequently leads of itself to the memory of certain dreams, that led Freud of necessity to undertake the investigation of the structure, origin, and meaning of these, with what brilliant results psychologists are gradually beginning to realise.

Notes from the 1920 edition

Original notes are grouped by printed page. The text was extracted from the historical scan; some characters and note markers may contain recognition errors.

Printed page 223 ↩

  1. 1 Published in the Journal of Abnormal Psychology, April, 19g1I.
  2. 2 Féré, ‘Note sur un cas de paraplégie hystérique consécutive 4 un réve,’ C. R. Soc. de Biol., November, 1886, No. 41. ‘ A Contribution to the Pathology of Dreams,’ etc., Brain, 1887, vol. ix., p. 488.
  3. 3 See, for instance, de Messiéres, ‘ Les réves chez les hystériques,’ Thése de Bordeaux, 1895.
  4. 4 Waterman, ‘ Dreams as a Cause of Symptoms,’ Journal of Abnormal Psychology, October-November, 1910, vol. v., p. 196.

Printed page 224 ↩

  1. 1 See Chapter XII. Also A. A. Brill, ‘ Dreams and their Relation to the Neurosis,’ New York Med. Journ., April 23, 1910.
  2. 2 Ernest Jones, ‘ Der Alptraum in seiner Beziehung zu gewissen Formen des mittelalterlichen Aberglaubens,’ 1912.
  3. 3 Freud, ‘ Die Traumdeutung,’ 4° Aufl., 1914, S. 186.

Printed page 226 ↩

  1. 1 Erythrophobia, as distinguished from ereutophobia, the fear of blushing, to which this term is sometimes incorrectly applied.

Printed page 227 ↩

  1. 1 The meaning of both this dream and the previous one may be expressed by a sentence from Boccaccio’s ‘ Decameron’: ‘ Who willeth thee ill, dreameth thee ill.’

Printed page 230 ↩

  1. 1 A recent communication by Kreist to the Société de Psychologie (Journ. de psychol. norm. et path., IgIo, p. 252) contains a singular illustration of the prevailing tendency to be satisfied with the first steps of a psychological analysis. A certain married couple were continually in dispute, and a divorce was talked of. The husband, as is usual under such circumstances, recognised in himself an alternation of antipathy and tenderness. There was no apparent cause for the disharmony. Kreist hypnotised the husband, and found that his antipathy to his wife dated from a given dream, which had been previously forgotten. According to Kreist the whole trouble was due to this dream (!), and peace was restored as soon as the husband learned the trivial cause of it. It would be interesting to know the later history of this touching episode.

About this reading edition

This page is an OCR-assisted transcription of Jones’s 1920 London reprint of the revised and enlarged edition. Paragraphs, section headings, original page locations, and page-grouped notes are presented for reading. The text has not yet received a complete line-by-line proofread against the scan, so occasional recognition errors may remain. Jones’s arguments are historical material, not current clinical guidance.

Jones, E. (1920). Some Instances of the Influence of Dreams on Waking Life. In Papers on psycho-analysis (Rev. & enl. ed., reprint, pp. 223–230). Baillière, Tindall and Cox.