History of Psychoanalysis

Papers on Psycho-Analysis · Part II: Papers on dreams

A Forgotten Dream. Note on the Œdipus Saving Phantasy

Ernest JonesChapter X of XLPrinted pages 231–241About 22 min

A close reading of a recovered dream and its associations, including what Jones calls the Œdipus saving phantasy.

Type size
Chapter X
p. 231 notes

Note on the Œdipus Saving Phantasy

A MATTER established by experience in dream analysis is that all dreams of the same night are concerned with different aspects of the same theme. During the investigation of one dream it often happens that the memory of a second one, which has been forgotten through repression, is recovered as soon as the repressing resistance that caused it to be forgotten has been overcome through psycho-analysis of the first. The following dream analysis’ is a striking example of this, and as it presents other features of general interest it would seem to be worth relating. It should be mentioned that the subject of’ the analysis, a University teacher of biology, is quite normal, and presents no neuropathic traits.

I.

The subject dreamed that he was at the mouth of a dark cave full of water; it had two openings, side by side. Opposite to him was a puppy, whining to come out. Coming behind the puppy were two cats. He set out to rescue the puppy, which during the procedure seemed to fuse into his personality. He was in great danger of drowning, but clung to some bushes which were at the side of the cave, and at last safely emerged. Standing outside was his father, who seemed quite unconcerned. He wondered that his father had not helped him, and supposed it was because he had not realised the extent of the danger. He p. 232 notes impressed on his father the danger he had come through, and boastfully told him that he had saved himself without any help. The dream belongs to a class that can almost be called typical; any one practised in dream analysis can at once interpret it without any trouble. Emergence, after great difficulty, from a dark chamber containing water, is a very usual way for unconscious thoughts aboyt the birth act to be expressed;? the dark cave in the dream, With its two openings and its bushy (=hairy) entrance, represents the mother’s body, or womb, enclosing the uterine waters. In mythology the situation is often reversed by the hero being placed in an enclosing chamber and put into, or on to, water,? such as with Moses in the bulrushes, Noah in the ark, and so on; as a rule the more important the hero, especially when he is made the ancestor of all mankind, the more extensive is the flood of water. The subject of the present dream and his wife ardently desire a child, but their parental longings have to be contented with a puppy dog, to which they are very much attached. On the dream day ’—1.e., the day immediately preceding the dream— this dog got accidentally shut up in a distant room, from which the subject, notified by the whining, released him, an incident which doubtless served as one of the instigators of the dream. Behind this simple wish, however, which was, of course, in no way repressed—though it was invested with a painful feelingtone because it could not be fulfilled—lay deeper and older thoughts. In the dream the subject identified himself with the dog, the two fusing into one; it was thus a question of his own birth. This explains the subsequent appearance of the two cats, an uncomplimentary reference to his younger sisters, who have a marked propensity to quarrelling.? Dreams and phantasies concerning one’s own birth are very common, especially in childhood, and are generally connected with the desire to have children of one’s own. The phantasies in question are of considerable importance in psychopathology, since they constitute the basis of such phobias as those of being buried alive, of being shut in an enclosed space (claustrophobia), and many others. The whole range of morbid anxiety phenomena, p. 233 notes indeed, stand in an intimate relation to the actual birth event, which is the first anxiety experience of the individual, and which serves as an archetype for all later manifestations (compression, suffocation, etc.)2

Appropriately enough for this interpretation is the fact that the enclosed cavity in the dream was in the earth. Mother Earth as a symbol for the mother is familiar to us in poetry, mythology, and folk-lore;? in Watts’s celebrated picture, ‘ The All Pervading,’ for instance, it is used actually to symbolise the female generative organs. On the dream-day the subject had been reading some literature of the Middle Ages in which it described how the devil frequented remote and inaccessible caverns in the earth, and, as he was familiar with my theory that the idea of the devil is a projection of the child’s thoughts concerning the father,®? he had readily perceived the symbolic significance of the description.: The portrayal of the act of birth by a deed of saving life 1s a theme to which much attention has been paid of late by Freud * and others.© It originates in the gratitude felt by the child to his mother on hearing that his life was a gift made by her at the risk of her own. The phantasy of saving her life, or some one’s in her presence, represents the grateful desire to repay her by doing for her what she did for him—i.e., by making her a gift of a life. To give a woman a child signifies to make her a mother, and the phantasy just mentioned naturally becomes associated in the unconscious with incestuous thoughts; the full rendering of it, of course quite repressed, would therefore run ‘ to shew his affection and gratitude to the mother for begetting him, by begetting a child by her in return.’ The idea of gift is never very far in this connection; with a woman the thought of having a child by a certain man is often expressed in the words ‘ to give me a child of his.’ The later elaborations p. 234 notes of this phantasy of saving are very important for the psychology of many impulses and reactions in adult life, but for an account of them the reader must be referred to the writings of Freud and Rank.

The deeper layer of the dream thus represents an old childhood wish of the subject’s to have a child by his mother, but there is more than this. One cannot fail to be struck by the plain hint of his relation to his father in the matter, which in the light.of our interpretation becomes quite comprehensible. He had nurtured feelings of hostility to his father, unconscious since early childhood, which had originated partly in his jealousy at being disturbed by him in the exclusive possession of his mother’s affection; and partly in the rebuff with which his father had treated his desire for enlightenment on forbidden topics. In the dream these feelings obtain full revenge. Not only does he proudly demonstrate to the father his independence in these matters, and that he is master of the situation without any external help or advice, but he further dispenses with the father altogether in regard to the question of his own birth. He has begotten himself, is his own father, like the divinities and heroes of old.2. He has satisfactorily solved the problem of birth in general, and of his own in particular, and the dream is a panegyric of his superiority to his father.

After we had completed the main part of the analysis® the subject asked me to pursue further one part of it in particular— namely, the dog symbolism—and this because of the frequency with which the same symbolism occurred in his dreams. In the present dream he identifies himself with the dog while in the act of putting himself in his father’s place;* the dog thus symbolises in turn the subject’s child, himself, and his father. From earlier analyses we knew that in his unconscious the idea of dogs was closely associated with that of sexuality,° and p. 235 notes that in his dreams a dog frequently symbolised either his father or mother. On the dream-day he had been reading a book on totemism and animal-ancestry, and it was evident that the Same association between animals and ancestors existed in his unconscious as exists in the savage mind. The question arose as to how this association had originally got formed in his mind. There is no need to go into the details of the matter here, which was largely concerned with infantile sadistic conceptions, but the first point to come out has a direct bearing on the present theme. The only dog the subject had had much to do with in early years was one he had been given at the age of eight bya man he was very fond of, and to which he became extraordinarily attached. When he was unhappy he would take it for a long walk and spend the whole day as far as possible from home. The dog was a female one, but was invariably referred to at home as ‘he,’ and could thus be used to symbolise a person of either sex; her name was ‘Fanny.’ The only woman he had known of this name in his youth was a Miss Fanny W., a lady some ten years younger than his mother. He had been very fond of her and her mother, who were especially kind to him. ‘Whenever he visited them Miss W. used to inquire with peculiar friendliness after his mother, whom she had been intimate with in earlier years, but with whom, for irrelevant reasons, she was no longer on visiting terms; the idea of Miss W. was thus closely connected with that of his mother At this point the subject suddenly recalled an earlier dream of the same night, which he had thought of on waking, but which he had then quite forgotten until this moment; we have next to turn our attention to this dream.

Il.

He was in his father’s office with Mr. W., who was expounding

to him his genealogy and early life. Mr. W., the father of Miss Fanny W., was an old man, who had been a colleague of his father’s and had worked in the same office. The subject had never seen much of him—he had died when the former was ten years old—and he had not to his knowledge thought of him for many years. The coincidence of his appearing in this particular dream is therefore certainly very striking.

p. 236 notes On the dream-day the subject had been thinking about a projected visit to his family home, where he had not been for several years, and had expressed the hope that his aged grandmother would be still alive—for the egocentric reason that he could then ask her about a number of matters concerning his infancy in which since psycho-analysis he had become interested; his mother had lately died, and he did not care to talk to his father about them. Now his grandmother’s daughter (his aunt on the father’s side) had married Mr. W.’s son, now dead, a relationship more clearly shewn in the accompanying table;

Mr. W.=Granny W. _Grandmother. p. 237 notes it. On paying closer attention to the details it was noticed that the main figure really constituted what is known as a “composite person’ (Sammelperson; being composed of three persons condensed into one. Although it seemed in the dream definitely to be Mr. W., and the place was the only one where the subject had ever seen him, the face resembled a Mr. A. rather than Mr. W.; the two men were in fact very much alike in appearance. Mr. A. was an elderly man in whose office the subject had worked some years ago, and who ever since had owed him a considerable sum of money. Owing to financial difficulties he had not been able to pay this off, but had promised to pay a quarter of it on a date some eight months before that of the dream. He had not fulfilled the promise, and this had

_ rather embarrassed the subject, particularly as he had just then to meet heavy expense in connection with a projected removal from one town to another. Two days before the dream, a week before the subject was to leave, the long-awaited cheque arrived, but he found to his chagrin that it was post-dated and payable only a month later. On the dream-day he wrote a somewhat stiff letter in acknowledgement, explaining his situation, and remarking that as he had closed his own bank account he would have to send the cheque to his father (in the same town that he was going to), and ‘trust to his honesty to - get the money back.’ While in the middle of writing the letter he noticed that the cheque was made out for twice the amount he expected, a discovery that led him to mollify his remarks and gratefully to thank Mr. A. for having done all that he could under the circumstances; we see here again the same alternation of friendliness and hostility that characterised the whole of his attitude towards the father and his substitutes.

The curious remark in regard to his father’s honesty was greatly ‘over-determined.’ It pointed in the first place to an unconscious identification of the father with the elderly Mr. A., the annoyance with the latter having evoked a manifestation of the old hostility towards the former. The remark was not only unwarranted in fact, but was quite pointless, for the father was a scrupulously honest man. According to the subject, the only unfair thing he had ever done in regard to money was to make a will recently in which he disinherited his son and left all his property to his two daughters. There were, it is true, special reasons for his doing so, and the subject p. 238 notes had not only acquiesced in it, but had even advised it; nevertheless it was plain that he had not entirely forgiven his father for — being so ready to overlook him. This reproach he had unconsciously linked to the old one about being kept in the dark as a child and dishonestly lied to on the topic of child-birth. The way in which this apparently strained association between the ideas of money and babies was forged cannot here be related, as it would necessitate too long a discussion; the cloacal connection will be evident to those familiar with psycho-analysis.*

Unlike both Mr. W. and Mr. A., however, the figure in the dream was quite bald and there was a wart by the side of the nose. These characteristics, and the upper half of the head in general, at once reminded the subject of Charles Darwin. The singular appropriateness will be admitted of the problem of personal origin being expounded by the author of ‘The Descent of Man’ and ‘The Origin of Species.’ As a student of biology the subject had greatly revered Darwin, who had, so to speak, answered the question he had propounded in vain to his own father; it was evident that unconsciously he had identified the two men, Darwin being to him what he had wished his father to be—an expounder of the problem of origin. Strangely enough, Darwin had on the dream-day been the topic of conversation between the subject and his wife. Being concerned at his overworking she had urged him to give up some of his routine teaching work so that he might devote himself more peacefully to his favourite pursuit of scientific research, and had considerately volunteered to do with less money. The talk drifted on to the endowment of research, and the subject remarked what a fortunate thing it was for mankind that Darwin had inherited enough money from his father to enable him to pursue his investigations undeterred by material considerations. He here was evidently identifying himself in his unconscious— that realm of unlimited egoism? with Darwin, 1.e., once more with his father—and was at the same time mutely reproaching his father for not having bestowed him with more worldly goods. His father had spent many years in the service of other people, and had quixotically refused to seize opportunities for his own advancement. In the sentence written to Mr. A., referring to his father, the subject had unwittingly expressed p. 239 notes the wish that his father had in fact been a little less pedantically honest, so that he might have been able to bestow him with more money.

The three persons figuring in the dream are thus all substitutes for the father. Each one is connected both with the subject’s ‘money-complex’—1.e., his complaint that he was worried about money matters—and also with the deeper reproach against his father regarding the question of sexual curiosity Both these complexes are evident in the case of the Darwin component of the figure, as is the former with Mr. A. and the latter with Mr. W. The series may be completed by mentioning the following two facts. A prominent memory the subject had of Mr. A. was a morbid interest taken by the latter in the sexual thoughts and curiosity of children. As to the relation of the money complex to Mr. W., it is enough to say that he was closely connected with the subject’s father in the financial aspects of the business they were both concerned with. Both complexes were thus associated with each of the three constituent persons of the dream figure.

Ii].

The analysis just given of the two dreams, or two halves of a dream, confirm to the full Freud’s theory of dreams, which has been most precisely formulated by Rank? in the following terms: Der Traum stellt regelmdssig auf der Grundlage und mtt FAtlfe verdrangten, infanttl-sexuellen Materials aktuelle in der Regel auch erotische Wiinsche in verhillter und symbolisch eingekleideter Form als erfilltdar. (‘Dreams constantly present the fulfilment, in a concealed and symbolically veiled form, of various current wishes, usually of an erotic nature; they do so on the basis and with the help of repressed, infantile, psychosexual material.’)

We see that the dream as told, the ‘manifest content,’ is quite senseless and even absurd, but that the hidden meaning,

- or ‘latent content,’ revealed by analysis, is thoroughly intelligent and full of meaning. Further, that although the manifest content may seem to deal with situations that, so far as the psyche is concerned, are harmless or unimportant, the underlying thoughts are highly significant and are related to the most p. 240 intimate part of the subject’s personality. Behind the manifold processes in the dream structure—which by a superficial study might be mistaken for the true latent content—stands the primordial basis of all our mental activities, the Wish. The current wishes of the actual moment, the ones that aroused the memories which threatened to disturb the subject’s sleep, were two, one erotic, the other non-erotic—namely, the desire to have a child and the desire to be free from monetary cares; these two desires, however, were not really so independent as they appear. The current wishes aroused deeper and older repressed thoughts with which they were connected, and on the basis of which the dream was constructed. These deeper thoughts were, as always, of infantile and sexual origin. In the present case they concerned the most intimate relations of the subject to his parents: hostility, and to a less extent friendliness, towards his father, love and tenderness towards his mother. The natural desire to have a child awoke the old desire to repay his mother’s sacrifice for him by presenting her with another child—of their very own; in this he plays the double part of both the child loved by the mother, and the father who presents him to her.

We see further the exemplification of the initial thesis from which we started—namely, that different dreams of the same night are concerned with different aspects of the same theme. They often, as here, present different solutions of the same problem. In the earlier dream, the second here related, the father meets his childhood curiosity in a sympathetic and helpful manner; in the later dream he solves the problem without his father’s help, and defyingly replaces his father in respect to the loved mother. In the former his homosexual component is gratified, in the latter his heterosexual. In the latter he finds a man’s solution, adopting a masculine attitude, in the former he finds a woman’s, adopting a feminine attitude. We have here, therefore, an illustration of the bisexual nature of the normal man. With the present subject, as with most men, the homosexual components of his instinct were more deeply repressed than the heterosexual, and it is thus entirely comprehensible that the dream expressing the former components was the one that proved the more susceptible of being forgotten; the question as to which of two dreams will be first forgotten may seem to be merely a matter of chance, but we see that the laws of psychical determinism hold here just as rigorously as p. 241 elsewhere. Anyone trained in psycho-analysis will further perceive a good reason why, of two dreams relating to the begetting of children, it was in the feminine one that a moneycomplex came to expression. Still another refinement may be added of the analysis of the feminine dream. The subject had often as a child had the desire that the family doctor would present him with a baby of his own, and had elaborated phantasies in which he imagined himself the wife of this doctor, whom he greatly admired. The doctor had not only brought him and his sisters into the world, but had saved his life on two subsequent occasions when he was desperately ill; it was he who had presented him with the beloved dog Fanny, the dog so closely associated in his mind with the family of Mr. W. Mr. A. also was nearly associated with doctors, being the head of an agency for the sale of medical practices. As to Darwin, he was both a doctor himself and the son of a doctor. The three components of the figure that plays the masculine part in the dream, therefore, all portray features not only of the father,

as described above, but also of the family doctor who in the child’s eyes seemed the ‘bringer of children’ par excellence.

Many of the individual features of Freud’s dream theory are also illustrated in the analysis, the almost grotesque egocentricity of the dream thoughts, the mechanisms of condensation, displacement, and regressive dramatisation, and the importance as dream-instigators of incidents of the previous day. In the present case these were unusually numerous; we have noted the puppy dog shut up in the room, the reading about the devil inhabiting caverns, the book on ancestor-worship, the thought of the. projected visit home, the letter to Mr. A., the talk with the wife on money matters, and the reference to Darwin. Several of these cannot be described as being in any way psychically significant, but they had become associated to underlying complexes and thus proved. suitable material to be used in the manifesting of these complexes.

Notes from the 1920 edition

Original notes are grouped by printed page. The text was extracted from the historical scan; some characters and note markers may contain recognition errors.

Printed page 231 ↩

  1. 1 Published in the Journal of Abnormal Psychology, April, 1912. 2 It will be understood that in the following account most of the steps of the actual analysis are not mentioned, it not being the purpose of the present article to expound the technique of this.

Printed page 232 ↩

  1. 1 See Chapter VIII., p. 203.
  2. 2 See Otto Rank, ‘Der Mythus von der Geburt des Helden,’ 1909, S. 69-72.
  3. 3 This symbolism had an older source, less ungallant, in the fact that like so many other children, the subject used to regard all dogs as male and all cats as female.

Printed page 233 ↩

  1. 1 Freud, ‘ Die Traumdeutung,’ 1909, S. 199. 2 This subject is fully dealt with in Dieterich’s ‘ Mutter Erde,’ 1913.
  2. 3 ‘Der Alptraum in seiner Beziehung zu gewissen Formen des mittelterlichen Aberglaubens,’ 1912, chap. vi. _- 4 Freud, ‘ Beitrage zur Psychologie des Liebeslebens,’ Jahrbuch der Psychoanalyse, 1910, Bd. ii., S. 389.
  3. 5 Otto Rank, ‘ Belege zur Rettungsphantasie,’ Zentralbl. f. Psychoanalyse, Jahrg. i., S. 331; ‘ Die ‘‘Geburts-Rettungsphantasie’’ in Traum und Dichtung,’ Zeitschy. f. Psychoanalyse, Jahrg. ii., S. 43; and ‘Die Lohengrinsage,’ 1911, chap. vii., S. 87-131. Reik, ‘ Zur Rettungssymbolik,’ Zentralbl, f. Psychoanalyse, Jahrg. i., S. 499, Stekel,..‘ Einige Bemerkungen zur Kettungsphantasie und die Analyse eines Rettungstraumes,’ Zentralbl. f. Psychoanalyse, Jahrg.i., S. 591.

Printed page 234 ↩

  1. 1 See Freud, ‘ Die Traumdeutung,’ S. 180-187, and Ernest Jones, American Journal of Psychology, January, 1910, pp. 93-97.
  2. 2 See Rank, ‘ Der Mythus,’ op. cit. 3 At this point attention may be called to the striking resemblance between the dream-phantasy just detailed and the story of Gidipus, who saved his mother (—town) by solving the riddle of the Sphinx (psychologically the same riddle as that solved by our subject in his dream), married his mother, displaced his father, and reigned in his stead.
  3. 4 Cf. the expression, ‘To become top dog,’ which, as it happens, was a favourite one of his father’s.
  4. 5 This is, of course, quite common, as is indicated by the mere expression ‘ animal passion ’=sexual desire.

Printed page 235 ↩

  1. 1 This was the first step of an analysis which shewed that in the subject’s unconscious his mother and the dog Fanny had long been identified. In the dream, therefore, the subject saves his mother as well as himself, a more typical form of the saving phantasy.

Printed page 236 ↩

  1. Fanny. Son Aunt. Father= Mother. ¢
  2. Subject.
  3. it happens that he had, as a boy, taken a special interest in their courtship and marriage. Mr. W. and the grandmother could thus be brought into near connection, they being the parents of the same couple, a connection furthered by the circumstance that Mr. W.’s wife was always addressed by the subject as ‘Granny’ W. Inthe dream Mr. W. replaces the grandmother ‘in giving the subject the desired information about his origin and upbringing. Two wishes lie behind this apparently senseless replacement: first the old desire that the father would respond to his request for enlightenment about the problem of his birth, and secondly, the old revengeful desire that the father might resemble Mr. W. and his son (of the same generation as the father) in the respect of having departed from this life.
  4. More than this: On the dream-day the subject had wished to question his grandmother because his mother was no longer accessible. She therefore replaced the latter in his mind, and as she was replaced in the dream by Mr. W. we reach the conclusion that the figure of the latter stood not only for the father, but also for the mother; this reminds us of the original connection between the two via Fanny. The dream is thus seen to be built on the basis of childhood sexual curiosity, and the desire that the parents would gratify this.
  5. Though the basis of the dream is, as has just been explained, a childhood one, more current wishes also come to expression in

Printed page 237 ↩

  1. 1 Chapter VIII., p. tg1.

Printed page 238 ↩

  1. ti See Chapter’ XC. "p''679.
  2. * In the unconscious mind everyone believes in the omnipotence of his thoughts, in the irresistibility of his charms, and in the immortality of his soul.

Printed page 239 ↩

  1. 1 Otto Rank, ‘ Ein Traum, der sich selbst deutet,’ Jahrbuch der Psychoanalyse, 1910, Bd. ii., S. 519. Those who wish to read a really full dream analysis are referred to this excellent paper.

About this reading edition

This page is an OCR-assisted transcription of Jones’s 1920 London reprint of the revised and enlarged edition. Paragraphs, section headings, original page locations, and page-grouped notes are presented for reading. The text has not yet received a complete line-by-line proofread against the scan, so occasional recognition errors may remain. Jones’s arguments are historical material, not current clinical guidance.

Jones, E. (1920). A Forgotten Dream. Note on the Œdipus Saving Phantasy. In Papers on psycho-analysis (Rev. & enl. ed., reprint, pp. 231–241). Baillière, Tindall and Cox.